News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NY Fed rescues overnight lending market with $53B by PKop on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:33PM (#21001978)
To a large degree, they aren't accepting it. This is why around 2014 treasury holdings by rest of world stopped growing on net.

Many governments/central banks are trying to exit the $ and UST's and are buying gold instead of treasuries.

Ultimately, the US has quite a large amount of liabilities, and entitlement spending on retiring boomers coming due in the next few years. Currently, at the peak of the economic cycle, we are running $trillion deficits.

Imagine what happens if there is a recession? Even if there isn't, these fiscal deficits, along with our large trade deficit mean:

The rest of the world gives us real goods, we give them paper IOU's. The debt is not shrinking but is growing, and faster.

So, they are not tolerating it. Problem is, in the petrodollar system, the reason this whole ponzi could occur is dollars were needed to buy oil. Post-71 Nixon shock, the $ was as good as oil. Saudi and others only sold oil for dollars putting a floor on the value of dollar and incentivizing both oil exporters and rest of world to want to hold dollars, thus recycling their surpluses into treasury debt to both fund their export economies and fund our consumption.

This CANNOT continue because by definition it means rest of world works and produces for never ending, and ever growing, US consumption. Holding dollars, amidst a growing realization the Fed would have to monetize this debt and government would never pay it back in "real terms" has led many oil exporters to try to sell oil in other currencies, and countries generally to try to exit the dollar for trade.

Iraq[0], Libya, Iran, Russia, and Venezuela[1]. Do we see a pattern of what happens to nations that try to do this? They either get regime-changed or become enemy number one for US government. Do you think it is a coincidence that Venezuela has the largest oil reserves in the world and just happens to be the next country US is involved in pushing regime change (them or Iran)?

To read about this system of petrodollar recycling, and how/when it was created in the early 70's because of collapse of Bretton Woods, check out an this excerpt[3] from excellent book "The Global Minotaur: America, Europe and the Future of the Global Economy" by Yanis Varoufakas former Greek minister of finance.

Good thread [3] covering a broad summary of trade, the dollar, and petrodollar warfare [4]

[0] http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Iraq/Iraq_dollar_vs_euro.h...

[1] https://www.mintpressnews.com/petrodollar-warfare-the-common...

[3] https://www.yanisvaroufakis.eu/2011/02/10/surplus-recycling-...

[3] https://twitter.com/TheSuperbubble/status/109944882078459904...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrodollar_warfare

Re:NY Fed rescues overnight lending market with $53B by wonnage on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @03:22AM (#21003069)
> entitlement spending on retiring boomers coming due in the next few years

This is a frequently overblown fact. 12.4% of the population was >65 in 2000, increasing to 15.2% in 2006. So this huge incremental wave of retiring boomers is... 3% of the population.

> The rest of the world gives us real goods, we give them paper IOU's. This is fun to say but try paying for goods with a paper IOU. Chances are the store will prefer dollars, even though they're technically the same concept.

> Problem is, in the petrodollar system, the reason this whole ponzi could occur is dollars were needed to buy oil. Post-71 Nixon shock, the $ was as good as oil. Saudi and others only sold oil for dollars putting a floor on the value of dollar and incentivizing both oil exporters and rest of world to want to hold dollars, thus recycling their surpluses into treasury debt to both fund their export economies and fund our consumption.

People want dollars for various reasons. The dollar is stable relative to other currencies. They're harder for authoritarian governments to seize. There's inertia (It's already the reserve currency and working fine, so why change?). It's extremely liquid. All more valid reasons than this random oil conspiracy theory.

> This CANNOT continue because by definition it means rest of world works and produces for never ending, and ever growing, US consumption.

Not sure how this follows, at all.

> Holding dollars, amidst a growing realization the Fed would have to monetize this debt and government would never pay it back in "real terms" has led many oil exporters to try to sell oil in other currencies, and countries generally to try to exit the dollar for trade.

Nobody is exiting the dollar for trade. What're you gonna do, switch to euros? yuan?

HN and wacky economic conspiracy theories, name a more iconic duo.

Re:NY Fed rescues overnight lending market with $53B by kasey_junk on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:56AM (#21003962)
You’ve been able to trade petroyuan in Shanghai since early 2018. The volume there is made up almost exactly with what a less conspiracy based hypothesis would expect: domestic Chinese firms, Russians avoiding sanctions & arbitraging actors.

There has not been a mass exodus to the yuan, quite the opposite China has been manipulating it up through that entire time.

Euro denominated oil is likely to come online in the next year or 2. The E.U. started a benchmark program this summer. Roseneft (a big Russian producer) switched to Euros a couple of weeks ago.

Re:NY Fed rescues overnight lending market with $53B by ilaksh on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @02:29PM (#21008447)
That doesn't seem like a convincing argument against the whole petrodollar "conspiracy". It seems like there is no assurance that trading in these alternative currencies can't increase dramatically among other countries.
Re:NY Fed rescues overnight lending market with $53B by kasey_junk on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:14PM (#21010894)
I think the conspiracy theory is backwards. We didn’t use hegemony to make people us petrodollars. They used petrodollars because it made the most sense. By dramatically increasing our use of sanctions we’ve turned that on its head. And we are going to see petrodollars become less important.

We aren’t going to go to war with China, Russia or the Euro zone for switching off petrodollars. The opposite conclusion is ludicrous.

Re:NY Fed rescues overnight lending market with $53B by simula67 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:18PM (#21002141)
Thank you. This is such an important topic and I wish more Americans understood and discussed this.
Re:NY Fed rescues overnight lending market with $53B by ilaksh on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @01:05AM (#21002508)
This is along the lines of how I was interpreting things. Its really scary. I would be happy to hear a convincing argument against this version of reality if such a thing is possible and if anyone is able to make one.