Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by einpoklum on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:54PM
(#20989721)
Graduating university does not an intellectual make.
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by indecisive_user on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:03PM
(#20989794)
Sure, at the individual level graduating from a top tier university or with a phd doesn't mean you're an "intellectual".
But from a population standpoint, the two are certainly correlated. The number of congress people should be large enough to assume population level statistics unless there's some serious biases _against_ intellectuals running for or winning political races.
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by shsjdhsi on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:20PM
(#20990266)
I disagree. After a certain amount of the pop. gets certain degrees, it’s just a cheapening of the degree. For example, despite having an eng PhD from a top 10 (5?) university in the US, I know I wouldn’t have been awarded one from a top 100 50 years ago. The standards were higher
And you don’t cheapen what you treasure.
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by einpoklum on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:14AM
(#21005037)
> The number of congress people should be large enough to assume population level statistics
It's not a uniform sample. In fact, it's not even sampling from the same population - it's a set of samples of size 1...
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by SoylentOrange on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:03PM
(#20990164)
You are 100% right.
However I was trying to respond to the parent commenter’s point about mediocrity. I was trying to craft a simple metric which would speak to mediocrity. It’s an imperfect metric for sure.
If anyone wants to crunch the numbers, I would be excited to see the percentage of US Congresspeople with serious educational attainments vs Japanese, French, German, Canadian, or any other similar body.