News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by skissane on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:28PM (#20989571)
In France, there is still such a thing as a "celebrity philosopher".
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by TheOtherHobbes on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:52PM (#20989713)
Last time I was in Paris, in La Villette, there was a busker playing incredibly dissonant serial music. On an accordion.

He had an audience - admittedly not a huge audience, but he certainly wasn't being ignored. There aren't many places that would happen.

Francophone cultures - and especially in Paris and Montreal - seem more comfortable with people who are clever, thinky, maybe creative, and a bit unusual, than Anglophone cultures.

The UK and US have their own version, but access is controlled more by class rather than raw talent. France is hardly class-free, but it seems more open to blue sky philosophy than the US, which seems to be impressed primarily by thought leadership in a corporate context, or social and academic theories with dogmatic authoritarian overtones - even among progressives - than in knock-about philosophical experimentation for the sake of it.

Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by happytoexplain on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:23PM (#20990285)
Your point may be going over my head, but can you elaborate (re-elaborate?) on the connection between intellectual-friendly culture and the quality of street musicians?
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by np_tedious on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:52PM (#20990437)
He was playing something pretty obscure and avant garde, and still drew a small crowd.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serialism

The suggestion is that this is less likely to occur in an American city.

Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by bobthechef on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:45PM (#20989670)
And that's good how? It's just snobbish pseudo-intellectualism. If anything, it can be more corrosive because it produces a suffocating, toxic atmosphere of fraud. Groupies and scenesters.
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by jarvl on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:00PM (#20989768)
I'm not sure I agree.

I can apply your statement to other celebrity academics: scientists, astromoners, physicists, etc. And for all of those professions I have a hard time believing that any "celebrity" (i.e. Steven Hawking, Brian Cox, Noam Chomsky) that emerges from them produces a "toxic atmosphere of fraud" or undermines the work of other professionals in the field. But it may depend on who you consider a "celebrity".

Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by Nasrudith on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:59PM (#20990149)
Pardon the pun but to be frank there is a point at least in the case of the French. I know the term best in the context of Bruno Latour's dribble. Given the sheer nationalism draped for why he was supported it seemed to be motivated reasoning as a desperate cling to superiority like their language board trying desperately to avoid loanwords, and insistence upon very narrow culinary definitions. There seems to be an isolationist complex about not wanting to have to compete. (Which as a national neurosis is not unique - see American exceptionalism.)

That aside Latour was infamously an originator of the "Post Truth" and his support for utter nonsense. It is true that social aspects affecting what science is considered, achieves mindahare, is funded, and catches on and progresses. It is undeniable as seen by the derth of statistics and genetics papers from the USSR when both were declared bourgeoisie pseudosciences. It affecting what is actually right? Hell no. Although at least to his credit he realized what a monster he had created.

Philosophy isn't neccessarily bad but it isn't neccessarily good either. Given that it is often defined via its independence from the real world there are many spaces to explore. Which includes the potential to be absolute pseudouintellectual or antiintellectual nonsense. That makes it different from the other examples - they are verifiable and it is possible to call bullshit and outright prove them wrong.

"Celebrity philisopher" may just mean that it flatters preconceptions without the ability to be countered via hard proof that "no the moon is not and cannot be made of cheese".

Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by notacoward on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:10PM (#20990213)
So what constitutes "real intellectualism" to you? What subjects or presentations are fit for "genuine" intellectual curiosity, which are limited to "groupies and scenesters"? Either you're being snobbish yourself, or you're doing exactly what anti-intellectuals have always done to cast intellectualism of any kind into disrepute.
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by codesushi42 on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:51PM (#20989705)
Is that what really happens in France?
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life by Biganon on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:37PM (#20990008)
With "philosophers" like Bernard-Henri Lévy, who keeps getting invited to TV shows despite being considered a phoney by pretty much all his colleagues: yes.