News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by baybal2 on Saturday September 14, 2019 @06:44PM (#20974329)
There is an already cobalt free lithium battery chemistry there LiFePO4 — been in use for more than a decade, and is a preferred one by commercial and heavy duty EVs because of superior battery life at the cost of capacity.

The new chemistry mentioned has no commercial use cases unless it beats LiFePO4 in its niche or surpasses mainstream chemistries, which is a big stretch.

BYD intentionally went full in onto LiFePO4 because they very well foreseen cobalt shortages.

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by Gibbon1 on Saturday September 14, 2019 @07:07PM (#20974439)
I think the article says iron fluoride potentially has double the capacity as conventional cathodes but in it's raw form isn't stable enough. I think it's a big deal because 'even' a 50% increase in energy density is a huge deal. And doubling means the absolute end of internal combustion powered cars.

Who knows. I remember articles about LiFePO4 back in the late 1990's. Took them a long time to solve the problem of high cathode resistance and put them into production. Seems like there is a huge space to explore here and little to judge what will work.

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by p1mrx on Saturday September 14, 2019 @06:48PM (#20974360)
LiFePO₄ is also useful for replacing alkaline batteries in small devices, because the cell voltage (3.2V) is approximately 1.5V x 2.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by baybal2 on Saturday September 14, 2019 @07:20PM (#20974490)
Add to that, in real world conditions very few battery packs can reach 160-170Wh/kg (and hold it after years of use,) while 140Wh/kg LFP been a reality for the last 5 years.

They can be more fully charged and discharged, while other lithium cells have to overprovision massively to extend the battery life. This alone makes it so that energy density advantage of NCA cells is thrown out of the window if you count the effective battery pack capacity with BMS sparing cell life.

And in comparison to NCA cells, LFPs are much, much cheaper, exactly because of the aforementioned cobalt and nickel use. Phosphates are, after all, spent by tonnes as a fertiliser.

Add to that that have a very, very rare trait among chemical batteries — they are stable at high temperatures.

This allows for making them work in very hot climates without liquid cooling which would've added a lot to cost and weight.

It also allows them to take more regen current, and therefore they don't suffer from as big range reduction from "regen choke" in hot climates. From the above, we also get their higher charge current tolerance, meaning that they can be charged faster.

Another very useful trait is their resistance to swell, offgassing and high dimensional stability. This allows for bigger, higher volume fill ratio cells, reducing the battery pack size, and thus its housing mass. Near all "brick" cells are LFP for this exact reason.

They age more evenly, unlike other chemistries, and that too contributes to ease of making bigger cells, and lessen the need for battery balancing, reducing charging times.

EV makers are stuck with small 18650s because it is very hard to increase cell sizes without not worrying about swelling. And the lower volume to area ratio of 18650s also lead to noticeable mass disadvantage.

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by elihu on Saturday September 14, 2019 @10:40PM (#20975238)
> Add to that, in real world conditions very few battery packs can reach 160-170Wh/kg (and hold it after years of use,)

Here's a tesla battery pack that comes in at 212 Wh/kg if the specifications are accurate: https://www.evwest.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=4&prod...

> And in comparison to NCA cells, LFPs are much, much cheaper, exactly because of the aforementioned cobalt and nickel use. Phosphates are, after all, spent by tonnes as a fertiliser.

Is there a good source for LFP that actually is cheaper than plain lithium ion? I've been looking at doing an electric conversion, and it seems like they tend to run about $400-500 per kwh, whereas lithium ion tends to be more like $300-400. I can believe that LFP is cheaper to make, but if that were so, it seems like it ought to be reflected in retail prices unless vendors are selling them at a huge markup. (I've only looked into this recently, so I don't know if battery prices have spiked because of tariffs on China or something like that or this is just the normal retail price.)

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by baybal2 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:48AM (#20975621)
> Here's a tesla battery pack that comes in at 212 Wh/kg if the specifications are accurate:

The question is how much of that is overprovisioned for extra battery life

LFP cost more retail, mostly thanks to fewer makers selling on open market, but lower wholesale price on LFP is something quite certain.

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by elihu on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:52AM (#20975789)
I expect that's probably the true capacity; i.e. you wouldn't want to use more than 80% of that or so if you want the battery to last a long time.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by cagenut on Saturday September 14, 2019 @09:25PM (#20974989)
> it is very hard to increase cell sizes without not worrying about swelling

thank you. i've always wondered why they aren't just the size of like a soda can, or a thermos.

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by robocat on Saturday September 14, 2019 @10:17PM (#20975169)
Although 26650 (26mm diameter x 650mm length) Li-Ion are reasonably common.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by jillesvangurp on Sunday September 15, 2019 @03:57AM (#20976112)
Almost all EVs have much better energy density than that. The Model 3 has about 246 wh/kg. Most of the new EVs on the market right now are probably ballpark above 200 wh/kg and pretty much all of them offer warranties of 8 years for 70% of their capacity. That would be about 170 wh/kg after 8 years.

400 Wh/kg batteries are starting to reach the market pretty soon (interesting for aviation).

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by baybal2 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @08:07AM (#20976862)
Remember, the battery pack energy density vs cell energy density is a very different thing. Model S whole pack's energy density is modest 125wh/kg, way, way less than that of individual cells
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by kenhwang on Saturday September 14, 2019 @10:12PM (#20975144)
Just curious, who else besides Tesla is using 18650s? Or even NCA?
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by baybal2 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:59AM (#20975658)
Zotye, Trumpchi, few FAW OEM vehicles, mostly for the ease of air cooling
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by kenhwang on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:41AM (#20975762)
Interesting. I'm not sure I trust NCA enough to rely on air-cooling, but it's hard to deny they're very attractive on the price/performance side.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by baybal2 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @03:44AM (#20976079)
I meant them using 18650 size for ease of cooling. What I saw were them having battery packs with zigzagging air channels in between few rows of 18650s, nothing about the chemistry they use
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by Gibbon1 on Saturday September 14, 2019 @07:15PM (#20974466)
Other advantage is LiFePO4 is a lot safer than cobalt based batteries.

My company abandoned cobalt lithium ion batteries in our products because installers will mount our product in utility closets and then people will do things like store cardboard boxes in there.

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by mitjak on Saturday September 14, 2019 @08:57PM (#20974870)
cardboard boxes. in closets?!?!
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by maxerickson on Saturday September 14, 2019 @09:04PM (#20974907)
They mean that the space should be set aside for the equipment, not used for the equipment and also storage.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by Gibbon1 on Saturday September 14, 2019 @09:45PM (#20975065)
In commercial you can sort of trust they won't do that. Or it's on them if they do. But with residential properties yeah no. You go look and there is a closet with a water heater and they've got boxes and cleaning supplies stored in there.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by zdragnar on Saturday September 14, 2019 @09:20PM (#20974972)
Given the opening reference to safety, I'd assumed the problem work cardboard boxes was fire risk.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by maxerickson on Saturday September 14, 2019 @09:35PM (#20975024)
Sure. You dedicate the space to the equipment for safety reasons.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by StavrosK on Saturday September 14, 2019 @07:54PM (#20974621)
What does the voltage depend on? It's interesting and odd to me that it'd be an inherent property of the chemistry.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by detaro on Saturday September 14, 2019 @08:07PM (#20974676)
It is an inherent property of the chemistry. It's a property of the electrode materials and how they release/accept electrons during oxidation/reduction (with voltage being a measure of the energy transferred per electron). Keyword is "Standard electrode potential".
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by StavrosK on Saturday September 14, 2019 @08:17PM (#20974715)
I'll read up on it, thanks. I'd expect that it was a function of the electrode area or another physical property, so this interests me, thanks again.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by eyegor on Saturday September 14, 2019 @07:55PM (#20974626)
Off topic, but how did you write a subscript character? The hn format page doesn't allude to any markdown/html/rtf support.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by MontyCarloHall on Saturday September 14, 2019 @07:56PM (#20974634)
By using the Unicode "subscript four" character (https://www.compart.com/en/unicode/U+2084)

₀₁₂₃₄₅₆₇₈₉

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by p1mrx on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:43AM (#20975605)
Yeah, I just googled "subscript four" and copied from the first result. There's probably a correct way to do it.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by TJSomething on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:50AM (#20975784)
The method I've come up with is to install an IME (fcitx) that has a addon that can search the Unicode database for a character. So, I press a key combo, type "subscript four", and press enter.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by detaro on Saturday September 14, 2019 @07:56PM (#20974632)
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by starky on Saturday September 14, 2019 @11:25PM (#20975383)
Totally different type of cells. LCO and NMC batteries which this would theoretically replace are energy cells with a specific energy of around 200Wh/kg. These are used when total energy matters, but you don't need high charge/discharge rates, such as with a laptop or cellphone.

LFP like you are talking about are considered power cells (along with Manganese Spinel). The specific energy is about half of an energy cell at around 90-120 Wh/kg. These are that cells you use when you want the stored energy quickly, such as with an electric car or power tools.

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by baybal2 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:53AM (#20975635)
> cells with a specific energy of around 200Wh/kg.

The talk is about specific energy of the whole pack, not cells alone. After you take into consideration higher wiring, casing, and cooling weight, the mass advantage of NCA cells will not look so apparent.

Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by eyegor on Saturday September 14, 2019 @07:47PM (#20974583)
There's also traditional lithium polymer batteries which tend to use aluminum and copper as their anode/cathode. Of course they aren't king for density or safety but they certainly don't use cobalt. https://www.genstattu.com/blog/what-is-lipo-battery-pack-con...
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by AstralStorm on Saturday September 14, 2019 @09:41PM (#20975051)
Nobody wants batteries of lower capacity though. This LiFeF (or whatever it's called) chemistry promises higher capacity.
Re:New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and N... by jillesvangurp on Sunday September 15, 2019 @03:45AM (#20976080)
It depends. Grid level storage is mostly about cost per kwh. not kilos per kwh. Energy density matters for small devices and transportation but these are not the only applications.