Re:Malcolm Gladwell on Hiring: the Mismatch Problem
by noonespecial on Wednesday June 04, 2008 @11:38PM
(#209640)
This is exactly what always bothered me about Google's white board testing (and testing like it at other big firms). It lets them know that you can do pointers and O notation but it completely misses the specific kind of tenacity that seems to make great programmers great.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Malcolm Gladwell on Hiring: the Mismatch Problem
by sarehu on Wednesday June 04, 2008 @11:52PM
(#209651)
But it does filter out people who don't have that tenacity. Those people who do have that kind of tenacity would already have learned about pointers and O notation.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell on Hiring: the Mismatch Problem
by acgourley on Thursday June 05, 2008 @12:23AM
(#209660)
It might not identify the best hackers (who can agree how to measure that, anyway) but it at least identifies a kind of hacker.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell on Hiring: the Mismatch Problem
by tptacek on Thursday June 05, 2008 @12:09AM
(#209657)
It's hard to see how you can be a great coder without understanding big-O. The better example to use is logic puzzles.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell on Hiring: the Mismatch Problem
by cdr on Thursday June 05, 2008 @11:22AM
(#209963)
I think the point is more to weed out people that can't do pointers and Big O than to determine greatness.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell on Hiring: the Mismatch Problem
by MaysonL on Saturday June 07, 2008 @03:42AM
(#211445)
Personally, I've always (well, at least since I quit programming assembler for a living[72-79]) felt that pointers, especially C type pointers, were evil, and any language that has them available without some hoop jumping or big warning signs, is to be avoided.