This whole thing smacks of corruption.
Soviet Union used the army to police immigration as well.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_force
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility_maximization_problem
Let's say 1 Anduril Widget would stop 10 border crossings/year on the southern border, but only 1/yr on the Canadian border. If I have 100 widgets, allocating them all to the southern border is the objectively superior employment of my assets. Only if my marginal utility per widget drops to preventing <1 crossing per year in the SOUTH should I even CONSIDER shifting resources to the northern border.
If they are going to build it and hand it of to border patrol, then Congress should fund it with the border patrols budget. Which they won’t, because this is as useless as a physical wall. So funding it with the money taxpayers allocated for the DoD is the definition of corruption.
It's a longer border, making it harder to man with...manpower.
Or maybe it’s dealing with the other nuclear powers.
Stopping people coming over the border to be residents is probably not in the top 10 of national defense priorities.
Honestly, as a matter of policy I don’t think it’s even something we are trying to do since immigration is so good for GDP, and nothing else really matters as much as growing GDP.
And where do you intend to stop the invading armies, if not....at your border?
>>>Stopping people coming over the border to be residents is probably not in the top 10 of national defense priorities.
Well, let's take a look at the 2018 National Defense Strategy: https://dod.defense.gov/Portals/1/Documents/pubs/2018-Nation...
Page 4, Defense Objectives, first line: -Defending the homeland from attack
That's vague enough to cover infiltration of terrorist organizations across the border.
Do you imagine border patrol plays a key strategic role in war? What would be an example of that from history?
"Defend everywhere" makes for a very poor Commander's Intent or Mission Statement. If you are defending "inside the border"...you've already failed at stopping your adversary AT the border. It also violates almost half of the Principles of War (mass, objective, economy of force, simplicity). Reference Appendix B of [6].
>>>Do you imagine border patrol plays a key strategic role in war? What would be an example of that from history?
From[1]: "Pakistani patrols began patrolling in territory controlled by India in January 1965, which was followed by attacks by both countries on each other's posts on 8 April 1965.[44][45] Initially involving border police from both nations, the disputed area soon witnessed intermittent skirmishes between the countries' armed forces."
Re: [2][3]These Soviet-Japanese border conflicts would have 2nd and 3rd order effects on military doctrine, development, and strategic focus (the Japanese stopped poking the Bear and focused on China). The Soviets gained some confidence in their operational doctrine and gained confidence fighting the Japanese (who they last fought against, and lost to, in the 1904-1905 Russo-Japanese War).
Reference [4] describes how the Soviets managed border security during their Afghanistan war.
Reference [5] has a short section on "Border Security in Contemporary Counterinsurgency" to summarize border control issues from Vietnam to Afghanistan to Iraq. It particularly points out the significant political ramifications of cross-border insurgents and counter-insurgency operations.
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Pakistani_War_of_1965
[2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Lake_Khasan
[3]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battles_of_Khalkhin_Gol
[4]https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13518046.2015.10...
[5]https://apps.dtic.mil/docs/citations/ADA503298
[6]https://www.marines.mil/News/Publications/MCPEL/Electronic-L...
Border security is THE most basic, fundamental responsibility of national defense. The US has just spent so frickin' long with benign powers on its land borders, and so focused on global expeditionary operations, that its border security efforts have atrophied. That said, national defense is now an over-arching term that includes a mix of law enforcement and military responsibilities and tasks. Note that securing our airspace "borders" largely falls onto Combat Air Patrols conducted by the various state Air National Guards, typically flying F-16s or F-15s.
>>>I am unaware of any Latin American terrorist groups threatening the USA.
Maybe not Latin American ones, but Al Qaeda just called for renewed attacks on the US in the wake of the 9/11 anniversary.[1] We KNOW that illegal aliens are crossing into the US traveling from as far as west/central Africa. [2] West Africa already has an Islamic terrorism problem.[3] From a risk assessment/risk management perspective, it is wise to allocate resources to reduce the chance of AQ or ISIS agents sneaking across our southern border, which leaks like a sieve.
>>>If the US/Mexico border is a defense issue, then it should be entirely militarized?
I think most major countries handle it as a national-level law enforcement responsibility, but sometimes there are still significant military forces involved.
As a point of comparison, China uses Army forces for border security, in addition to other agencies.[4] Russia's primary border force is a law-enforcement organization.[5]
[1]https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/al-qaeda-chief-issues...
[2]https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2019-06-02/watch-first-large-...
[3]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boko_Haram
[4]https://china-defense.blogspot.com/2017/09/the-second-line-p...
[5]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_Service_of_the_Federal_...