News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heidegger, the homesick philosopher by earthboundkid on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:08PM (#20958161)
> and other Heideggerian ideas, which have nothing to do with Nazism

That's begging the question.

We want to examine his writings to figure out a) how important is the biographical question to his work and b) how bad were the Nazis and why? Maybe thinking in terms of "Dasein" leads inevitably to death camps. Maybe not. But you can't just assume there's no connection (or that there is one). You have to argue it out.

Re:Heidegger, the homesick philosopher by madacoo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:14PM (#20958192)
I think the claim that Dasein has to do with Nazism would need to be demonstrated. I think for any idea it is reasonable to assume it doesn't have anything to do with Nazism until demonstrated otherwise. Dasein's throwness, so far as I can see, doesn't have anything to do with Nazism.

Of course there is always the possibility for any idea that it leads to death camps. But it is rather hard to exhaustively explore the consequences of anything.

It could well be, however, that having an affilation with Nazism increases the likelihood that your ideas lead to death camps. Although even that ought to be deomnstrated rather than assumed.

Re:Heidegger, the homesick philosopher by earthboundkid on Sunday September 15, 2019 @03:35PM (#20979062)
For an idea in general, sure. But Heidegger literally joined the Nazi party and never repented publicly. So there is a burden of proof on the ideas he specifically created to show that his Nazism was unrelated and accidental to the idea.