I was trying to buy new renter's insurance, since the previous one got expired like 3 months before that. So I was for 3 months without renter's insurance, when I quoted with Cover. That's just to say that there was no relationship between the date of the junk mail and the expiration of the previous policy.
I got the quote from Cover, because I was seeing the ads and thought they could offer me a good deal. A week later I started getting this insurance junk mail.
There’s a few other ways, like soft pulls against your credit report that usually flag you as interested in insurance. Some companies make it their business to know when your insurance expires. There’s lots of data brokers out there mixing data in a pretty invasive way that will get you into lists.
Also, most (if not all) insurance carriers do not sell personal data and in fact go to great lengths to protect your data. It’s against the law in some cases or breach of contract between agents like Cover (which is probably why Karn is asking who you received mail from).
Disclosure: I work at an insurance carrier (not Cover)