News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by jdavis703 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:39PM (#20947303)
There's three paths:

1) Rent cap landlords. The landlords will cry Big Government.

2) Abolish single family-only zoning and legalize backyard cottages, townhomes and small apartments. The homeowners will cry Big Government.

3) Do nothing. Watch as more people start living in tents or endure super-commutes that snarl your traffic and worsen climate change.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by dgzl on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:10PM (#20947529)
I'm not a landlord or homeowner, and 1 makes me cry Big Government.

What if something crazy happens to the economy, say the dollar gets devalued, and all you have is rental property for income? Realistically you would raise your rental price.... But wait, there's a cap, and you can't.

2) "legalizing backyard cottages" is actually against Big Government, and I'm with you there.

You're forgetting another option: deregulate and let the market compete.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by wahern on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:31PM (#20947662)
> What if something crazy happens to the economy, say the dollar gets devalued, and all you have is rental property for income?

In San Francisco rent control is indexed to inflation. If the dollar is devalued, inflation increases, and you get to increase your rent more. The same is true for Oregon's new law, which permits 7% increases in addition to inflation.

> You're forgetting another option: deregulate and let the market compete.

Rent control is about providing housing security and controlling volatility. Over the long-term unfettered markets may produce optimal supply, but in the short-term people can easily be pushed onto the street. As Keynes said, "economists set themselves too easy, too useless a task if in tempestuous seasons they can only tell us that when the storm is past the ocean is flat again". (The more famous bit is, "in the long term we're all dead.")

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by refurb on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:57PM (#20947815)
SF is capped at 60% of CPI. Inflation is 10%, you can get 6%. Doesn’t take long for that to add up.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by crashedsnow on Thursday September 12, 2019 @12:30AM (#20948001)
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by refurb on Thursday September 12, 2019 @12:55AM (#20948125)
Let me restate that, if inflation was 10%, you’d only be able to increase by 6%, so you’d be losing 4% per year, which adds up quickly.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by fzeroracer on Thursday September 12, 2019 @12:14AM (#20947904)
Deregulate doesn't work when people won't sell. What do you do when highly wealthy people buy property and then never sell? You can't simply slash all of the regulations because regulations aren't the reason why they're not selling.

In fact, they're not selling because of market dynamics. Their property is becoming more valuable over time because no one else is selling, which means any property that does sell does so at an extreme premium. If you were an investor: Would you sell off your stock when your stock is performing strongly and continually growing?

Make no mistake. There is no free market happening here.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by slavik81 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @02:59AM (#20948744)
> What do you do when highly wealthy people buy property and then never sell?

Tax them. Inefficient use of land is a good sign that the property tax is too low. If the government charged a property tax rate that roughly matched the property value increase, there would be no gain just by sitting on the property. You'd have to put the land to productive use to actually make a profit.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by c22 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:57PM (#20947817)
If the economy crashes is the best outcome for a large population to simultaneously become priced out of their homes? Policy has to consider its effects on society as a whole, not limit itself to one myopic viewpoint.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by usaar333 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @01:13AM (#20948221)
> 2) "legalizing backyard cottages" is actually against Big Government, and I'm with you there.

The criticism is that big government (state level) is blocking smaller governments (cities) from making policies that fit the smaller community.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by rtpg on Thursday September 12, 2019 @12:28AM (#20947988)
- If the dollar gets devalued, other things will drop in price as well

- Laws can change in this case, as they have here. laws are a dynamic system

- If you are making money from rental properties only, that means you own properties (as well as your own house in theory). Not only are you more well off than almost all the population, but you have goods that are worth a lot of money that you can sell (maybe at a loss but you still have a roof over your own head).

"deregulate and let the market compete" is the right answer. It's the owners that don't allow for it.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 12, 2019 @01:08AM (#20948197)
> If the dollar gets devalued, other things will drop in price as well

When a currency is devalued, the price of things denominated in that currency increases.

> Laws can change in this case, as they have here. laws are a dynamic system

If you're going to pass a law allowing a rent increase every time the market would cause there to be a rent increase, I can suggest a much simpler alternative.

> If you are making money from rental properties only, that means you own properties (as well as your own house in theory). Not only are you more well off than almost all the population, but you have goods that are worth a lot of money that you can sell (maybe at a loss but you still have a roof over your own head).

That is not a valid assumption. Many small time landlords "own" the apartment building that they live in, but really the bank owns most of it and the rent is only enough to pay the mortgage and their own salary for managing the building. Require the rent to be capped at a level that causes the building to be worth less than the amount that you owe on the mortgage and there isn't anything for you to sell while you "still having a roof over your own head" -- you're just going to file for bankruptcy and have nothing.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by qroshan on Thursday September 12, 2019 @12:14AM (#20947897)
If the dollar gets devalued, then there is inflation, which the increase is tied to
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by zaroth on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:07PM (#20947511)
I dunno, a think a lot of homeowners would love to be able to build a little cottage in the back yard and cover half their mortgage renting it out.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by flatline on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:22PM (#20947616)
I was thinking that too; but then, a lot more would complain about the renters at their neighbors’ house, increased traffic, noise, problems with lower income renters, HOA violations, and the ungodly backup at the city permitting office for any minor construction.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by refurb on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:59PM (#20947824)
SF calls them ADUs(auxiliary dwelling units) and incentivized people to build them.

A lot of people don’t want to because once you’ve rented it out, the tenant can never be kicked out unless they break the law.

Do you want to sign up for someone living in your backyard for the next 20 years?

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by zaroth on Thursday September 12, 2019 @12:45AM (#20948079)
Well then they didn’t really incentivize people to build them!

An ADU should be like renting a room in your house. Exempt from fair housing laws, and at worst a non-guaranteed lease renewal, if not a simple 30 day notice.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by kchamplewski on Thursday September 12, 2019 @02:49AM (#20948705)
But the point of fair housing laws is to protect tenants. If everyone's building these and renting them with no fair housing protections, you've effectively just abolished fair housing laws without actually repealing them.

To me it feels like the sensible thing to do here is to either actually abolish the fair housing laws if tenants don't really need those protections, or have them apply to these new constructions as well since tenants do need them.

A stance in the middle makes no sense considering the intention of these laws.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by zaroth on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:00AM (#20950437)
A stance in the middle would apply to just these ADUs specifically, because they are somewhere in the middle between;

a) renting out a room in your house (where fair housing laws already don't apply) and,

b) renting out a fully distinct dwelling unit, where fair house laws definitely apply and serve an important function.

ADUs are always going to be a small percentage of the overall housing market, so lessening housing regulations around ADUs specifically is definitely not the same as abolishing fair housing laws entirely.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by refurb on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:39AM (#20950720)
I agree! I get the sense that many more people would build ADUs and rent out units if they knew they had more control over them. I’m not saying we should get rid of all tenant protections, but could make them a little more fair for the owners.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by ralusek on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:04PM (#20947479)
I'm a landlord and would love decreased housing regulations, even if it decreases the value of my property by increasing supply.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by TheReveller on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:12PM (#20947544)
When regulations allow for denser housing land prices go up because you can put more rentable dwellings in the same space.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by dgzl on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:24PM (#20947623)
Land prices go up because that's what it's worth. If the government says "you can't do this profitable stuff on your land", then the land is less valuable.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @01:07AM (#20948186)
I don't know where to stand on this issue. I wish everyone could afford basic living spaces, but if they could, there would be way more people, and the planet clearly cannot sustain that.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by bronson on Thursday September 12, 2019 @01:31AM (#20948323)
Preventing renters from living in high density housing will make the number of people on the planet go down?
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @01:41AM (#20948375)
SF isn't uniquely expensive. Every city with opportunity has a huge premium. It's all for the same reasons.

I'm not sure if I wish they'd go away.

If housing were more affordable, we could easily have 10B people on the planet right now. Most people truly want to have families. They want homes to raise those families. People can't go own reproducing forever. Could we have had 2% population increase over the last 30 years in the US instead of 1%?

Yes, but we'd already be over 10B people. In another 30 years, we'd be at close to 20B. It's not sustainable.

And even if it was, it's not necessarily a better situation. Who's to say that education, health care, food and other basic necessities wouldn't be more scarce and cause the overall cost of living to be even higher? Inequality would almost certainly be much worse.

The Malthusian trap plagued the world since the beginning of mankind. Until the industrial revolution, life for the average person was getting substantially worse over time. Then suddenly, productivity growth outpaced population growth, and we went through -- objectively the best time in human history. This is a time that includes monstrosities like the world wars and the threat of nuclear winter, and it it's BY FAR the best time humanity has ever seen.

Productivity growth is starting to decline. Do I think that making housing more affordable and jump-starting population growth to keep GDP numbers increasing at a steady clip is a good trade off? No.

Cheap housing sounds great. But I don't think it's a miracle pill. There are unintended consequences to everything. I wish we lived in a fantasy Utopia where everyone could be hold hands and be happy all day, but we don't.

Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by dgzl on Thursday September 12, 2019 @03:04AM (#20948778)
I suppose if people suffer less and love more, they reproduce more. I believe the world can sustain many times more people than it currently does, but only if we spread out. Cities are not good places for people who can't sustain it.
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by exfed on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:00PM (#20947454)
It may only apply to LA, but this whole (regulatory) issue seems deeply related to another similar article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20806752
Re:California Approves Statewide Rent Control by malandrew on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:58PM (#20947439)
Well if you explicitly pass things as “reversing a commit” instead of making a new hack to control unintended consequences, it’s harder to complain about big government since you’re making it smaller not larger.