S&P (and the rest of the market, really) can depreciate over a year and you'd just be losing your money.
Why bother day trading?
Index funds can take quite a hit in a bad market. I am very careful to avoid big slumps in my portfolio value, even if it means not being invested for a month or two.
Because for me stocks look like a hot potato game. Literally the whole reasoning behind price is you can sell it higher to someone later.
The price is not supported by anything (book value is 10 to 100 times lower) and you don't get anything because liabilities come first on overvalued assets.
With a bit of active management, I manage to achieve 6-8% each year, but I avoid large negative hits that an index fund might endure in a bad market.
So, I'm sort of returning similar returns to market, but with less volatility in the bad times. I'm sorta happy with that.
The S&P 500 returns about 10%/year since its inception. (7% if you adjust for inflation.)
If you think you're going to turn £5k into £500k in a year, forget it! But turning £5k into £5.3k is certainly doable.
Scale that initial portfolio to £5m, and you can take home £300k with relative ease in a good market- that's a very comfortable income for most people.