Re:Hackers Hit Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey in a ‘SIM Swap’
by michaelt on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:56AM
(#20940258)
You're correct: You could TOTP from a java phone app, a tablet, an airgapped computer, a non-airgapped PC you were really confident of the security of, and so on.
That's why I said "bad for" rather than "impossible for" :)
After all, you'd still be excluding all the people who don't have any of those. Like my 90-year-old neighbour who only has a landline phone.
I've helped maybe 50 employees set up VPN access at my workplace, and at least 2 of them said they didn't have any way to TOTP independently of the laptop we were issuing them with.
This only true if you're willing to define everything beyond the most mundane "dumb phone" as a "smartphone". One of my friends has a long list of exciting problems which ends up meaning he doesn't own what anyone these days would consider a smartphone.
But it's not like he uses carrier pigeons. His phone does have a (monochrome) screen and is quite capable of running software, it's just the software has to be crappy mobile Java from last century. However TOTP is trivial, you probably can't do it in your head but you definitely can do it in a Java 1.0 implementation and so sure enough it can be run on those phones.
On a brand new Pixel of course you vaguely wave your phone near the screen, it reads a QR code and sets everything up, he has to instead laboriously transcribe a secret value using T9 input, but the same effect is achieved - a changing code that he can input to prove he knows the shared secret.