News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s not just p=0.048 vs. p=0.052 by thanatropism on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @08:32AM (#20939329)
P-values are a sub-optimal but okay-ish of quantifying a Popperian hypothesis (a designed-to-be-refutable conjecture). The mathematics is not the problem, the problem is carving science (which in my view (and Quine's and others's) is pretty much defined by the unity of science) in testable morcels.

None of the great achievements of science (Newton, Darwin, Mendeleyev, etc.) were obtained on the basis of Popperian demarcationism/conjectures-and-refutations -- they were obtained by positing a large framework and patching together the empirical case for it.

Re:It’s not just p=0.048 vs. p=0.052 by lonelappde on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @08:52AM (#20939506)
Your great achievements in science exclude all real world applications (engineering, pharmaceuticals, etc), where the critical details of a hypothesis don't fit on a t-shirt
Re:It’s not just p=0.048 vs. p=0.052 by thanatropism on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:51AM (#20940187)
Note that I said "science", not "engineering". Engineering is driven by usefulness and profit.

Falsificationism isn't a stupid idea; it's even useful at a personal improvement level. But pharma or materials research use it because it tends to lead to good results, not because it's the very definition of what's worthwhile knowledge.

Re:It’s not just p=0.048 vs. p=0.052 by Quekid5 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @04:55PM (#20944597)
Turns out that once you invent a system for "acceptance" (p < 0.05 or whatever), people will game it. Who knew?