To attempt to summarize in a way that answers your questions: First do you know how to do the work and use your own expertise to adapt to circumstances or do you follow specific direction, training, and escalation procedures as dictated by management? If you are following a script as trained and have someone overseeing you as you work then you are an employee. If you know what to do and get only summary instructions then you are likely a contractor. Second, if you are hired by a cleaning company to extend their cleaning capacity using their methods and equipment then you are likely an employee, but if you are hired by a software company to sweep their floors whenever they get really dirty then you are probably a contractor. Finally, if you do cleaning on your own for various clients and are hired to do cleaning then you are likely a contractor, but if you clean for one client by their instruction and with their oversight and support then you are probably an employee. Note that each of these criteria has substantial wiggle room and the idea is they all work together to support a decision one way or the other.
> First do you know how to do the work and use your own expertise to adapt to circumstances or do you follow specific direction, training, and escalation procedures as dictated by management? ... If you know what to do and get only summary instructions then you are likely a contractor
Surely Uber drivers already know how to drive. I'm not sure whether they're under obligation to follow GPS instructions.
> Second, if you are hired by a cleaning company to extend their cleaning capacity using their methods and equipment then you are likely an employee, but if you are hired by a software company to sweep their floors whenever they get really dirty then you are probably a contractor.
The Uber driver uses her own equipment although you could argue that they use Uber's methods.
> if you do cleaning on your own for various clients and are hired to do cleaning then you are likely a contractor, but if you clean for one client by their instruction and with their oversight and support then you are probably an employee
In my experience, almost every single Uber I've been in drives for Lyft as well.
UberX, no, the GPS is a suggested route. UberPool, yes, you have to follow the GPS as instructed.
> The Uber driver uses her own equipment although you could argue that they use Uber's methods.
This is where I tend to agree, with caveats. A rideshare driver is a contractor. But when it comes to compensation Uber and Lyft want to act as an employer. Currently, compensation has been trending down to the point it's becoming a unprofitable for the driver. A contractor would be able to negotiate a rate saying, "I'll drive for $0.55/mile." What we currently have is an email to all "contractors" stating the rate starting today is X/mile. That sounds more like an employer notice than a contract negotiation.
In a few cases my contract negotiations actually involved choosing between hourly or weekly, with differences in effective pay based on overhead for both me and the employer.
By that logic all taxi drivers are employees of the cities of their medallion, because cities set the taxi driver rates.
> the person performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business
It’s hard to say that offering rides is not Uber’s core business. There might be an argument that Uber is just a matching service, but that’s an argument to make, not self-evident.
This sort of stuff is happening a lot in construction and cleaning services as well. If you run a business, the people that do the core part of your business should be considered employees, or else all of labor law becomes pointless.
Unintended Consequences, arriving.
There will be no impact to those at all.
That is actually how most (sub)contractors in the construction world currently have things set up for legal reasons.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but you're summarizing the ABC Test. The question here is, what does the new labor bill mean?
Or is it the case that the new labor bill is "just" an embodiment of the ABC Test. If so, please state that clearly. I don't get that right now from your comment.
I'd argue that if you deserve benefits like everyone else.
Especially ridiculous is the situation some people I know of are in. They are working two or three part-time jobs because they can't find a full-time position. The places that employ them have many part-time positions, and fewer full-time positions. And these people don't get benefits.
So you've got people who are working 40+ hours a week, for employers who have enough hours to work to have full-time employees, but instead have part-time job openings instead.
All so that the employers don't have to pay for benefits.
This will force companies to hire more employees, true, but at the cost of a much smaller overall workforce. Remember that cost is a constraint for businesses.
Depends what is more valuable from a human + capitalism perspective, fewer work opportunities that pay better or more competition and “starter/flexible” work overall.
That's what people predict about minimum wage increases too. Yet the effect has always been smaller than predicted, sometimes even non-existent.
It's a subtle distinction, but one that I suspect would survive legal scrutiny.
When the gov't made noises about small business tax reform people screamed bloody murder and they had to climb down. Which only shows you how pervasive this kind of 'contracting' as tax avoidance actually is.
I must admit that I don't know enough of both situations to say much.
There seems to be quite a bit of vitriol online about the rule changes in the UK though.
I do remember reading the rules when I became a contractor a few years back and thinking: Ok, so I'm inside IR35, going to use an umbrella company as it's simpler. Was told that i was a fool and contract was outside IR35. As far as I could tell, nobody meet, or indeed, could meet the substitution clause.
Examples of a contractor here would be: hiring a third-party graphic designer for a few months while you ramp up hiring at a startup.
So, you would also need to be sure that they were:
>free from control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work
And:
>person is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation or business
> free from control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work
An independent contractor should be free to work when, where, and how they want. IE, you can't demand a contractor show up from 9-5 at your office, wearing a company uniform, and following employee policy.
> the person performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business
for example, a company that sells software, might hire a contractor to update their online advertising. The company doesn't sell online advertising or have any expertise in it, and they don't have a need for a full time position for online advertiser.
this one is going to be interesting for uber and lyft. right now, they identify and brand themselves as a ride sharing company. So rides ARE their business model. They might, for example, be able to pivot into a software company that licenses their ride-hailing software to drivers (who are license the software to help run their own independent businesses), then maybe they can get around this after some work. but right now its appears that drivers work for uber and lyft to deliver services to Uber/Lyft customers.
> person is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation or business
this is the most straight forward of them all. If an IC provides their services, the same service, to more than one company, that's a good indication that they are running their own business and not working as an employee for another. Here, Uber and Lyft actually benefit from each other because a lot of drivers drive for both Uber and Lyft. Thats why we've seen both uber and lyft drop their exclusivity arrangements with drivers in recent years.
You can ask them to dust, but can’t order them to dust a certain way. Of course you can make requests - don’t use cleaning product XYZ because I’m allergic, don’t dust the China because it’s too fragile, etc. But I suppose at some point it could be argued that too many such requests cross over into essentially supervising how they dust.
I think you’re right about contracting out for help. If you have employees already, and then you expect another person to join in and operate just as an employee would, why wouldn’t they also be considered an employee? I’m sure there could be some loopholes however.
> a person providing labor or services for remuneration shall be considered an employee rather than an independent contractor unless the hiring entity demonstrates that the person is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work, the person performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business, and the person is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation or business.
Under these conditions, what position would qualify as a contractor?
The first clause
> free from control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work
seems awfully broad. If I contract someone to clean my house, I would hope I have some control and direction of the person in connection to them cleaning my house. Or am I reading this wrong.
The second clause
> the person performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business
means I can't contract out work that I normally do? So if I'm a cleaner, I can't contract out other cleaners if I'm swamped.
The third clause
> person is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation or business
I don't really know what that means
Can someone shed some light on the text?
[0] https://legiscan.com/CA/text/AB5/2019