News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by yters on Monday September 09, 2019 @03:16PM (#20921328)
If we can just name zero dimension space as 'not space,' we could solve the problem much more easily by renaming 'space' as 'not space' instead of relying on convoluted analogies with holograms.
Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by oarabbus_ on Monday September 09, 2019 @03:25PM (#20921436)
I fail to see how this simplifies anything or makes more sense than the provided analogies; could you elaborate?
Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by yters on Monday September 09, 2019 @03:30PM (#20921517)
I fail to see how the hologram concept explains anything. Is my OS bootup process a hologram? Is the evolution of the universe from the big bang a hologram? What is not a hologram?

'Hologram' just seems to be a loose analogy for the concept that 'something complex came from something simple.'

On the other hand, the holographic nail sounds pretty neat.

Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by throwaway_law on Monday September 09, 2019 @03:48PM (#20921701)
>I fail to see how the hologram concept explains anything.

Think about where Classical Physics breaks down (at the big bang and black holes/singularity).

So if you, as a higher dimensional being, fall into a black hole (a lower dimensional space) where does all that higher dimensional information go? Well like a hologram, the idea is the information gets recorded on the surface of a black hole, or event horizon. In short its like a 3D object being able to exist in/on a 2D plain.

If a hologram doesn't work for you, maybe try thinking about fractal geometry where the perimeter of an object can measure infinity while simultaneously the volume is perfectly measurable and well defined.

Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by yters on Monday September 09, 2019 @03:54PM (#20921768)
Or a bitstring...

It's unclear what is so important about the 'hologram'.

What they really seem to be trying to do is explain how we get something from nothing, with ever more convoluted mathematical abstractions to try and avoid the inherent logical contradiction.

Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by pharke on Tuesday September 10, 2019 @07:51AM (#20927185)
The basic idea is that all of the information required to recreate a higher dimensional space is encoded in a lower dimensional space. The information is "spread across" the lower dimension in that each point encodes a lower fidelity representation of the whole.

Seriously though, look up how holograms work. There's a lot of thought provoking aspects to them and it's no wonder they've inspired a lot of novel thought about the nature of the universe.

Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday September 10, 2019 @07:57AM (#20927213)
That doesn't seem to explain anything. The higher-dimensional space isn't low-resolution. We don't live in a flickery monochrome universe?
Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by pharke on Tuesday September 10, 2019 @01:33PM (#20930822)
The higher dimensional space has "full resolution" since it is the summation of all of the data in the lower dimensional space. Any given part of the lower dimensional space has less "resolution" or information because it is a smaller sample of the whole.
Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by throwaway_law on Tuesday September 10, 2019 @09:17AM (#20927767)
> We don't live in a flickery monochrome universe?

Yes according to Einstein we on a smooth fabric of spacetime that curves in the presence of these 3D objects...but Quantum Mechanics isn't such a smooth universe as you scale downward.

Re:A Hologram Suggests How Space Could Pop into Existence by infominer on Tuesday September 10, 2019 @11:20AM (#20929181)
https://www.amazon.com/Holographic-Universe-Revolutionary-Th...

The reason a hologram is interesting is that each of its parts contains the whole. Above book by Michael Talbot is a good introduction to the topic.