Re:The Decline Effect and the Scientific Method : The New Yo...
by john_horton on Tuesday January 11, 2011 @08:27AM
(#2091812)
I see your point---my point is that this article is not a good jumping off point for discussions about philosophy of science or epistemology (bold title notwithstanding). It's about bad statistical practice. More importantly, it's about a bad practice that is well-known (at least among statisticians) and has remedies.
More specifically I was commenting on this:
...For many scientists, the effect is especially troubling because of what it exposes about the scientific process. If replication is what separates the rigor of science from the squishiness of pseudoscience, where do we put all these rigorously validated findings that can no longer be proved?...