Indeed, plus people will still come knocking at their door for Python 2 issues. And if you tell them to contact someone else for support people will still be upset.
Imho communicating EOL is the only way to go. Others can pick up legacy support under a different name. People will find them and it will be clear it's a different team.
I fully support them in this. Either you support it right, or you abandon/sunset it clearly.
If someone else wants to step up and do the work, they can always do that on their own.