Re:Top Programming Languages 2019
by seanmcdirmid on Saturday September 07, 2019 @07:40PM
(#20907455)
It has a huge influence on the language being used. There are simply many kinds of “programming”, and thinking about it as a homogeneous activity is just going to yield ridiculous PL popularity lists that compare apples and oranges.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
It certainly does have a huge influence on the language being used, as do things like living in Nigeria, writing code to run on on-orbit satellites, and working at Microsoft. But I wouldn't venture to say that Nigerians, Microsoft employees, and space cadets are therefore not doing "software development", just that they're doing it under atypical circumstances. (And, as that list suggests, in the end all of us have some atypical circumstances.)
I do agree that people frequently overestimate the homogeneity of programming, and that this homogeneity makes such lists less useful. Still, I think it's a useful observation that in 1985 Paul Lansky was writing music in FORTRAN and electrical engineers were writing circuit simulators in FORTRAN, while today musicians tend to do their software development in PureData or something similar, while electrical engineers tend to use MATLAB, Octave, C++, or Python. And I think part of the nature of software development is that it's typically a highly collaborative activity --- a library written by an electrical engineer can be used by a musician, but usually only if they're using the same programming language.