News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brain surgeons don't hold cellphones next to their ears by Alex3917 on Wednesday June 04, 2008 @10:56AM (#208969)
They could at least find someone in the right field. What next, car mechanics reject evolution? It's especially ridiculous coming from Sanjay Gupta, the same shill that CNN keeps on staff to attack Michael Moore.
Re:Brain surgeons don't hold cellphones next to their ears by gojomo on Wednesday June 04, 2008 @01:25PM (#209134)
Gupta is a neurosurgeon like the other two doctors quoted; what field could possibly be better for a story about cell phones and brain cancers?

Gupta was CNN's medical correspondent long before facing off with Michael Moore, and with regard to 'Sicko', pointing out Moore's omissions and distortions is a public service.

Re:Brain surgeons don't hold cellphones next to their ears by Alex3917 on Wednesday June 04, 2008 @01:36PM (#209147)
"what field could possibly be better for a story about cell phones and brain cancers?"

A cancer researcher?

Re:Brain surgeons don't hold cellphones next to their ears by gojomo on Wednesday June 04, 2008 @02:25PM (#209205)
Perhaps, and the article did cite recent study results in both directions, though it didn't ask the researchers their personal practices.

For that general-audience question -- "what should people do while the question is open?" -- brain specialist doctors are a great source.

Sometimes practitioners can see patterns others miss. It was doctors directly treating gastric diseases who discovered the role of H. Pylori in stomach ulcers, against a mistaken medical consensus that had prevailed for decades.

Re:Brain surgeons don't hold cellphones next to their ears by LPTS on Thursday June 05, 2008 @04:10AM (#209764)
"Gupta is a neurosurgeon like the other two doctors quoted; what field could possibly be better for a story about cell phones and brain cancers?"

How about a 10th grade science student who understands what nonionizing radiation means.

"And now Sara will use what she learned in 9th grade science to tell us all why Dr. Gupta is a moron."

Re:Brain surgeons don't hold cellphones next to their ears by gojomo on Thursday June 05, 2008 @11:45PM (#210607)
So by your cocky and insulting tone, I assume you have 100% confidence that mobile phone radiation is harmless, and that the various studies indicating otherwise will all ultimately be refuted?
Re:Brain surgeons don't hold cellphones next to their ears by LPTS on Friday June 06, 2008 @02:34AM (#210654)
No. I only have about 75% confidence. But, I do have 100% confidence that Dr. Gupta of CNN news has no good reasons to think it does, and that, if it does, the mechanism is unknown.
Re:Brain surgeons don't hold cellphones next to their ears by gojomo on Friday June 06, 2008 @12:04PM (#210913)
The article's only comment about Dr. Gupta is that he uses an earpiece for his mobile phone. From that, you can divine that he's a 'moron', and 'has no good reasons' for his beliefs?

Maybe for him, a 25% chance the studies showing harm are correct (similar to your belief) is enough to justify the earpiece.