News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by codex on Sunday January 09, 2011 @10:22PM (#2087303)
The author argues for skepticism but is quick to dismiss global warming, apparently on the basis of a single webpage. Should not one also be skeptical of the skeptics, too?
Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by anamax on Sunday January 09, 2011 @11:34PM (#2087487)
> but is quick to dismiss global warming, apparently on the basis of a single webpage

Actually, he didn't. FWIW, he provided more evidence in support of his global warming skepticism than he did in support of his other skepticism, skepticism that you didn't question.

But, I'll play along. How much support should he have given for each of his arguments to satisfy you?

Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by Kaya on Monday January 10, 2011 @01:18AM (#2087688)
The author claims unequivocally that global warming is a hoax. Submitted as evidence is a page which one-sidedly discusses troubling, suspicious, and unseemly behavior by some climate scientists. That is bad, but not proof of a hoax--not by a long shot. Such a strong claim supported by such a weak source makes it appear (at least to the skeptical) that the author may not be equally skeptical of all sources or points of view. Confirmation bias is a known bug in the wetware which makes it hard to be truly objective about anything, try as we might.

Had the author made a weaker claim I'd have read the rest of the article with much less skepticism!

Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by anamax on Monday January 10, 2011 @11:04AM (#2088807)
Huh?

Telling us how he could have satisfied you wrt a different argument is interesting but he question was "How much support should he have given for each of his arguments to satisfy you?"

Note that he suggested skepticism wrt multiple things, suggesting that general skepticism is a good idea, yet you're only discussing one of them.

Suppose we conclude that skepticism wrt global warming is unwarranted. What, if anything, does that say about his general conclusion?

Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by codex on Monday January 10, 2011 @02:25PM (#2089423)
It is not my intent to invalidate the author's thesis. I attempted to point out that skepticism is not enough; one must also apply skepticism consistently to all sources in order to free oneself from unconscious cognitive bias. As evidence, I use the author's treatment of global warming, where the evidence supplied is far too poor to support the conclusion. It's not a matter of quantity--it's just a blog post, after all, and I would have been tolerant of zero support for his claims. But if the author does supply support, it shouldn't be so crappy to as to suggest that does not apply a skeptical viewpoint to his own sources.
Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by anamax on Tuesday January 11, 2011 @12:57AM (#2091091)
> I attempted to point out that skepticism is not enough; one must also apply skepticism consistently to all sources in order to free oneself from unconscious cognitive bias. As evidence, I use the author's treatment of global warming

Likewise, I use your treatment of his examples. As I pointed out, he provided better support for his global warming skepticism, which you rejected, than he did for his other skepticism, which you accepted.

Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by Alex3917 on Sunday January 09, 2011 @11:15PM (#2087436)
These days it seems like most self-described skeptics are morons. I'm not sure how we got to this point, but it's highly troubling.
Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by tensor on Monday January 10, 2011 @02:05AM (#2087778)
Absolutely not true. For example, the folks from the Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcast and related community are very objective.
Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by tsiki on Sunday January 09, 2011 @11:49PM (#2087521)
Indeed. It baffles me how many people think being skeptic means believing the opposite of what's commonly believed.
Re:Be Scientific (Skeptical) about Scientific Research by brc on Sunday January 09, 2011 @10:34PM (#2087342)
Yes, they should. All people making claims should be subject to scrutiny over vested interests, exaggerations, distortions and unwarranted attacks on other people in the same field. The same standards should be applied to all.