News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel? by nstom on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:47PM (#20862568)
When a tree dies that CO2 will mostly just be released into the air again. Planting trees is a measure to slow the immediate effects of fossil fuel usage, but not a long term solution. At some point you’ll run out of space for new trees.

It’s like fixing a leaky pipe by adding sponges. Sure, they’ll soak up the water and are cheap, but eventually you will run out of space for new sponges and have to pay for a plumber.

Re:Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel? by ddxxdd on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:56PM (#20862609)
It's more like fixing a leaky pipe by adding a patch that will last for centuries, that can pollinate itself and produce additional patches in the future, and that can be removed and used as a building material for a new house.
Re:Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel? by ElKrist on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @02:38AM (#20864155)
"and that can be removed and used as a building material for a new house."

I'm all for building wooden houses. But I can also imagine the amount of work (=> energy consumption) needed to convert theses trees we need to plant to "offset emissions" as new houses.

Transport the workers, feed the machines to chop the trees, the machines to transport the wood, to run the lumber-mill, to transport to the construction site etc. Unfortunately for now we still have: feeding machines => energy consumption => emissions

We can argue that this energy would have been needed anyway to build new houses. However I find it dangerous to couple a carbon reduction strategy to a substantial amount of an activity involving machines (construction). Are we going to need the amount of houses at the scale of the amount of trees we need to plant? In all parts of the world concerned (we don't want to move trees across the world anymore..)?

Re:Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel? by im3w1l on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @03:16AM (#20864285)
Unless you have a system in place to take responsibility from seed to logging to long term encapsulation I'll be highly skeptical of that.

What's to say it wont be slashed and burnt to make room for agriculture? What's to say the surplus of timber wont decrease the price and cause less trees to be planted elsewhere?

Re:Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel? by TeMPOraL on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @06:06AM (#20865114)
It's still sponges, not patches. They absorb the water, and you have to manage them. If you don't actively store them, the water will leak out. If you do actively store them and then hand off storage to someone else, the water will leak out when that someone stops paying attention.

The way to sequester carbon with trees is to cut them down when they're grown, and bury them somewhere where there's no air and no one will touch them for thousands of years, or otherwise store them in perpetuity while preventing decay or burning.

Re:Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel? by adrianN on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @09:11AM (#20866114)
Turning them into biochar is a slightly simpler proposal. Biochar is stable for a pretty long time. But of course the process of unburning all the coal we burned so far is not very viable.
Re:Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel? by lagadu on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @09:37AM (#20866329)
It's not an infinitely long term solution but it's a solution that buys us at the very least dozens, if not hundreds of years before we run out of space. Because no solution is ever infinite, given that the Sun isn't, it doesn't make sense to consider something that will potentially work for a hundred years as a non long term solution. By the time that solution stops being long term, we'll have far more advanced options to buy us another century of time.
Re:Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel? by richardwhiuk on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @07:18AM (#20865420)
That's all the CO2 lifecycle is in nature - Oil / Gas are basically large sponges which absorbed Carbon a long time ago, and were buried.

It's not impossible that we could grow a huge number of trees, and bury the resulting wood in a mountain-side to offset burning coal - but the amount of wood we'd need to bury might be prohibitively large.

(We've buried much worse things than wood :) ).