Looking back in time and given what's happened, would Google the Startup have been wise hosting their e-mail on Hotmail?
Consider the case of the UK PM's director of communications (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andy_Coulson#Renewed_allegation...). He was a newspaper editor that allegedly¹ instigated the use of phone cracking to get info on celebs and public figures. Of course once caught he denied having knowledge despite those doing the cracking saying that he instructed them to do it. Result: the peons get it in the neck and the top brass get positions of greater power.
I don't think Google are doing something like that but I'm sure more than one rogue elsewhere, in the past, was actually following orders.
¹ - weasel words!
Edit: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/phone-hacking... for anyone interested; they "lost" the emails sending them to India and of course a major newspaper never keeps backups ...
Add that to Google's Spam filtering, and the fact that I have to do nothing other than change some DNS records to get email for free, and it's really hard to bother to use something else.
How about Gnus? A single interface for mail, news, RSS, even files on your local machine. Regular expression-based filtering and sorting, on arbitrary fields in the header or body of messages. Adaptive scoring for prioritizing new messages. Auto-expiry and deletion of mail that you don't need to read. Completely extensible and hackable in Lisp.
And best of all, it's completely integrated with your favorite editor. ;)
Honestly, the GMail interface feels really limited to me. The one thing that GMail has -- or should have -- over other mail clients is its ability to search your mail archive. But GMail's search isn't even good! It doesn't match substrings, for example. Grepping a local mail spool is infinitely more powerful.
Almost none of those features matter to me, and sound like a bunch of extra junk I don't want. I want:
1) Webmail
2) with a reasonable interface
3) and a good spam filter
4) That has a ton of space to save my emails
5) That I don't have to administer.
(True, Gnus requires an initial configuration step -- maybe that counts as "administration" -- that the GMail web interface does not. But that's basically set-and-forget; it doesn't require the kind of monitoring or tweaking that running a mail server does.)
As far as the interface itself goes, if GMail works for you, that's great. Personally, I want:
1) to be able to check my mail from a terminal
2) a lot of control over pre-processing of mail, especially in filters that sort messages into groups/folders/labels. I find that simple string-match filters are really limiting.
3) to be able to copy and paste code and other data into and out of my email (e.g., to create new TODO items in Org mode), without using the mouse
4) to have the option to automate tasks like (3) when they become too frequent or annoying to do by hand
Different strokes, I guess. :)
Yep. :)
I used to access GMail through mutt, so I'm not totally opposed to doing something like this, but the OP was talking about not wanting to use GMail for privacy reasons, so using something like gnus to access your gmail account wasn't really on the table. And 'server side stuff' is all under 'do nothing' in my original post.
Roundcube is getting there slowly but surely:
Think about the things that go through e-mail, Powerpoint strategy decks, git commit messages (not too hard to recreate an entire git repo from the procession of messages being sent) etc. You have to be really careful about who gets access to that kind of information.
Of course, that assumption might come from the nearly 3000 unread emails in my inbox. Maybe they can keep up with my mail better than I can. (Not a "startup". Just some gal with some websites.)
Peace.
Would you write down everything you're doing, and post it to a competitor? Because if you work in an area Google's interested in then that's what you're doing, modulo a privacy policy you'll never find out they've violated (and has happened at least once before - http://articles.latimes.com/2010/sep/16/business/la-fi-googl...).
In this day and age, information travels fast enough that trying to keep a lid on your top talent is probably useless, but still good to have that information under your control.
The chances of Google stealing my idea is virtually nil, and if they wanted to steal it, they just have to go to my public website. Trying to hide what you're doing just seems silly to me in this day and age, so I'm just super-open about it; I'll blog, tweet, & FB what I'm doing on my start-up any time, and let the chips fall where they may...
Call me paranoid, but though Google's public motto may be "Do no evil" they're like every company and are after profit at the end of the day. Are you encrypting your e-mails? Is running your own mail server that hard, or does Google Apps offer that much benefit? Would you host your e-mail with Microsoft? Oracle? What really make's Google that different?
I am genuinely curious - Google seems to be treated by large portions of the startup community as if it were some charitable organisation, working for the benefit of man-kind in an open and free manner. Sure, they've done great things - Search, G-Mail, Android and loads of open source work. But they're still a company beholden to their shareholders, selling adverts based on mass data collection. At the end of the day, in my eyes, they're not fundamentally different from Apple, Microsoft or any other hugely funded mega-corp. I wouldn't store my secret sauces with those companies and their ever evolving market plans and TOSs. Am I overly cautious?