If I'm debugging a production issue and want to create a debug build from the same source to step through things, it would be nice if I could just build both debug and release, check the hash on the release to confirm it matches production, then start debugging, without reference to any external records or other systems.
Reproducible builds reduce the number of links in the chain needed to verify what you're really doing.
I mean, my response isn't entirely a rhetorical question. If there's a reason it wouldn't work I'd be curious what makes his situation different from mine.
This should have been the first question to ask yourself before trying to give advice.
...but what's really surprising is that it's surprising, since everybody is experienced with details in some context.
I hope we agree that justifying these deviations can be a lot of work and having reproducible builds would be easier.
In some of the plans I have seen, some deviations are tolerated but those deviations are spelled out in excruciating detail.
How have you dealt with this issue?