It used to be true(r). As you keep halving electricity consumption with each generation of products, eventually it isn't worth replacing just to save electricity, even if the new appliance is cheaper than the previous generation.
The problem with fridges is... they're almost all used 24/7.
Re-using old inefficient devices is fine/encourage-worthy in low-duty cycle applications, but there's just a lot less usage variability with fridges.
Efficiency gains have come from better compressors, and to a lesser extent increasing use of built in drawers and compartments, to stop all the cold pouring out the moment you open the door. Were they still insulated well, particularly as we have better materials to choose from, running costs could be reduced far more...
The real aim of modern appliance production seems to be to sell you the extended warranty/service contract.
Software and smarts SUCK on things that should be boring and reliable.
Worse yet, this is also directly related to the climate catastrophe issue. What would our world look like if we maximized for durability and repair?
I'll give you all a hint: we maximized for cost. And vehicle, appliance, junkyards, and trash dumps show it.
It's high time we make these companies with "manufactured limited reliability" to pay directly.
As for the increasing efficiency angle, I'm not buying it. I have a strong feeling that all efficiency gains are eaten by manufacturing. E.g. imagine you replace a fridge every 5 years, and each one is 2x as efficient as the previous one. I can't imagine how this uses less energy than running the first (least efficient) fridge for 15 years, once you account for the energy costs of designing, making and shipping the two newer fridges.