News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by brianpgordon on Sunday September 01, 2019 @10:58AM (#20852609)
Unfortunately, I think it's more likely that no matter how bad private healthcare gets, people in the deep red states mentioned in the article will just assume that socialized healthcare would be even worse and dig in their heels all the more out of redoubled fear of losing what little they have left.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by makomk on Sunday September 01, 2019 @11:15AM (#20852705)
I'm not sure they'd be wrong. The politicians pushing to socalize US healthcare are doing so on a platform of cutting costs and are generally pretty hostile to the idea of subsidising rural folks. Both of those point in the direction of healthcare reforms that kill off rural hospitals.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by tjr225 on Sunday September 01, 2019 @11:33AM (#20852784)
> platform of cutting costs

Costs should be cut, regardless of urban/rural, if we're being overcharged. Not sure what this has to do with killing off rural hospitals though.

> generally pretty hostile to the idea of subsidising rural folks

I have seen no evidence of this...do you care to elaborate or provide some links or something?

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by vidanay on Sunday September 01, 2019 @11:01AM (#20852631)
They will demand that the government "do something" (aka, a bail-out) whilst simultaneously complaining about their taxes.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by Scoundreller on Sunday September 01, 2019 @11:48AM (#20852874)
Don’t forget about subsidies and bailouts that are structured differently, but effectively that:

- cheap loans to terrible creditors that nobody else in the world would loan to

- not allowing governments to negotiate prices, even when they’re the buyer (drug prices)

- extra taxes, errr, tariffs, on their competitors

- exemptions from those same tariffs when its their input

- access to cheaper labour pools that no small business could possibly do the paper work for (various visas)

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by UncleEntity on Sunday September 01, 2019 @11:06AM (#20852656)
Or...

It could have been the plan all along to engineer a "market failure" so these people have no choice but to accept socialized healthcare even if they're vehemently opposed to it.

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by fucking_tragedy on Sunday September 01, 2019 @12:10PM (#20853000)
The ACA was a repackaging of Massachusetts' "RomneyCare" that was passed by Republicans in that state. The reason this legislature was chosen was because it was thought to be a bipartisan solution to rising healthcare costs.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by javagram on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:06PM (#20853322)
> Massachusetts' "RomneyCare" that was passed by Republicans in that state

FYI RomneyCare was passed by a supermajority of Democrats in the MA state legislature. They negotiated some parts with Governor Romney but the reform was not a “republican idea”. ObamaCare in general was not a republican plan - it was a moderate Democrat plan.

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by learc83 on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:15PM (#20853391)
The central idea, the individual mandate, came from a 1989 lecture by Stuart Butler, an economist at the conservative Heritage foundation. It originated as a conservative alternative to socialized healthcare.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by javagram on Monday September 02, 2019 @08:34PM (#20862780)
But in politics, the idea was pushed by democrats. The idea that Republicans came up with RomneyCare is simply false, it never would have happened if the Republican Party controlled Massachusetts. Look at actual republican controlled states and you can see what they did on health care pre-ACA and it was pretty much nothing.

People at conservative think tanks coming up with an idea doesn’t make it “republican”. In reality the party ignores many things that the heritage foundation or various other foundations or think tanks say, they’re much more focused on politics than on ideas.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_health_care_re...

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by learc83 on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:48PM (#20883687)
The Heritage Foundation is the flagship conservative think tank, Republican and conservative are synonymous in popular usage, so yeah I think it's safe to call their proposals Republican proposals despite the fact the party can't actually enact all of them.

And if we skip ahead 4 years to 1993, a Republican Senator introduced, a bill with 20 Republican co-sponsors including Bob Dole, Orrin Hatch, and Charles Grassley called the HEART bill.

That bill included an individual mandate, vouchers for low income individuals, and protection for prexisting conditions.

Not all Republicans supported this plan, but almost half of the Republican Senators including most of the leadership supported it. I'd call that a Republican plan--a plan based squarely on the proposal from the heritage foundation.

[dead]
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by lotsofpulp on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:03PM (#20853303)
The Democrats didn’t have the power to pass it by themselves, hence needing to compromise.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by povertyworld on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:05PM (#20853315)
It passed with not one vote from Republicans, so there was no need to compromise. Will your fake news post be downvoted? Of course not.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by ravitation on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:50PM (#20853590)
You're just wrong. Just because no republicans voted for it doesn't mean that enormous compromise was necessary to get certain independents and conservative democrats to vote for it, which is exactly what happened. The entire legislative approach to the ACA was to get a 60 vote filibuster-proof majority in the Senate (and subsequently to prevent the bill from returning to the Senate because of changes made by the House), in a Senate that only had 58 democrats.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by apathy on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:24PM (#20853423)
Remind us who tanked the public option in the ACA?

Hint: he was Al Gore’s running mate a decade prior. And he was never a republican.

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by darpa_escapee on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:02PM (#20853301)
You don't believe Democrats because they compromised with Republicans to get a bill passed?

If you recall, Republicans used the filibuster in the Senate, which meant Democrats needed a 60 vote supermajority to get a healthcare bill passed. When they floated the idea of a Medicare-for-all bill, Republicans promised to filibuster in the Senate.

Democrats compromised with Republicans on policy that Republicans wrote themselves, and Republicans still filibustered and not a single one of them voted in favor of it.

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by povertyworld on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:08PM (#20853333)
If not a single Republican voted for it that means the bill is entirely the responsibility of the Democrats. It is a bill created and passed exclusively by Democrats. The Democrats passed a Republican plan without one Republican vote. The Democrats had a filibuster proof supermajority, and they decided to pass Mitt Romney's healthcare plan. But it's all the Republicans fault. Obama didn't even try for a public option like he had promised during the campaign.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by apathy on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:27PM (#20853441)
Independent. The 60th vote was an independent who endorsed John McCain in preference to Obama.

How can one person manage to be so consistently incorrect?

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by shims on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:29PM (#20853450)
> If not a single Republican voted for it that means the bill is entirely the responsibility of the Democrats.

Every Democrat in the Senate voted for it, including two independents.

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by rosser on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:48PM (#20853571)
Can a mod please collapse or detach this thread? There's nought but noise here, unsurprisingly.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by slowmovintarget on Sunday September 01, 2019 @11:59AM (#20852932)
This shouldn't be downvoted, because this was was what the ACA was meant to do. Exacerbate the cost problem (which it has done), restrict doctor-run hospitals (which it does), and lead to a problem where the "solution" is a single-payer system so that 11% of the economy (back then), could be "captured".

Many democrats thought (and said so) that there was a huge problem of all this money moving around without government control. The first attempt, which failed badly under Hillary Clinton's leadership during her time as First Lady, failed because it tried to do everything at once. It could therefore be seen as a massive power-grab.

The ACA on the other hand, delivered an incremental approach that included lots of things people wanted: ignoring pre-existing conditions, broadening coverage. But it also did things like say there could be no new doctor-run hospitals, and existing ones could not add beds. Doctor-run hospitals, at the time, were actually a success of the free market in health care. Their outcomes in terms of patient recovery and survival rates were higher than state run hospitals. They were a direct threat to the idea that the government should run health care.

The ACA also set the stage for the failure of private medical insurance. We're in limbo on that score, but the needle has moved toward that failure.

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by guntars on Sunday September 01, 2019 @12:29PM (#20853121)
And now you’re being downvoted because all of this is unsourced speculation and people here don’t really care for that.
Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by ryguytilidie on Sunday September 01, 2019 @01:19PM (#20853404)
Also because he is literally blaming Hillary Clinton for stuff that happened while she was first lady.

I swear modern Republicanism is just agreeing with Donald Trump and blaming anything that goes wrong on Hillary or Obama.

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by slowmovintarget on Sunday September 01, 2019 @04:34PM (#20854726)
Hillary Clinton led the effort to reform health care during her husband's first term in office [1]. I am literally claiming that Hillary did things that she actually did. I'm sorry you weren't aware of history. That Hillary led this effort was actually noteworthy less for its failure and more for the fact that this was the first time a First Lady took a publicly visible hand in core policy-making.

I don't think Donald Trump is truly fit to be president, and I don't think the modern Republican party represents my views. Nor do I think Hillary Clinton was a suitable choice either. But disagreeing with the modern Democrat party is often met with derision, even if it is reasoned objection.

I actually remember the political discourse during President Clinton's first term, having been part of it back then. I remember the speeches Hillary Clinton gave as chair of the task force, including the notion that it was tragedy to allow so much of the economy to flow outside the purview of government. The notion of regulatory capture is not new [2].

It is my opinion that the purpose of the ACA was to lead to single-payer. It was the kind of boiled-frog strategy that Democrat party leaders had been using successfully for decades at the point ACA came a along.

The restrictions on doctor-owned hospitals are part of the law [3].

That the law would cause increased costs and dramatic deficits was predicted by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) [4, 5].

The way I formed my opinion was taking all of this into account, including the model Hillary's task force put forth in the 90s as being what Democrats actually wanted. It is a reasonable opinion that if the ACA didn't deliver all of the things from the original plan, yet it opened up many unsolved problems, that the intent was to "continue reform" and make the "natural solution" a single-payer system.

I do wish we could have discussion without every comment on politics becoming a college paper.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clinton_health_care_plan_of_19...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture

[3] https://www.cms.gov/medicare/fraud-and-abuse/physicianselfre...

[4] https://www.cbo.gov/topics/health-care/affordable-care-act

[5] https://www.factcheck.org/2017/03/cbos-obamacare-predictions...

Re:Nearly a quarter of U.S. rural hospitals are on the brink... by guntars on Monday September 02, 2019 @10:31AM (#20859300)
Thanks for adding sources. This is the first time I’ve heard about physician owned hospitals and I found this study useful:

https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/22856850/4558297...

TLDR; Previous research found that speciality physician owned hospitals (POHs) are treating less Medicare patients that are also healthier and focusing on more profitable patients while still receiving whatever benefits being a Medicare provider gets them. This lead to a blanket restrictions on all POHs in ACA. The above paper compared both specialty and non specialty POHs, which is what ACA actually targets, and found no significant differences between them and non POHs in terms of types of patients, cost of care and outcomes. This suggests that the policy has been too broad and is in need of a revision.