News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is Zoned Storage and the Zoned Storage Initiative? by loeg on Saturday August 31, 2019 @07:40PM (#20849497)
Zoned SMR storage has almost no use case outside of tape replacement.

The same drives configured in 100% random I/O mode lose a handful percent capacity and the tradeoff for SMR zones is awful: rewrite your entire filesystem stack (thousands of labor hours) and expect awful performance. For most businesses this is not an obvious win.

Meanwhile, big cheap dense SSDs get bigger, cheaper, and denser every day. You don't have to rototill your filesystem to use them effectively. So I don't see a lot of sense in investing in zoned filesystem support when archive tier bottom-dollar storage can just use the unzoned, marginally smaller spinning rust today, and switch to the unzoned, super lower write endurance flash media tomorrow.

Re:What Is Zoned Storage and the Zoned Storage Initiative? by klysm on Sunday September 01, 2019 @12:26AM (#20850474)
SMR does have a use case outside of tape replacement. It has higher density. Take a look at DropBox MagicPocket - they designed their entire storage system around SMR technology
Re:What Is Zoned Storage and the Zoned Storage Initiative? by loeg on Sunday September 01, 2019 @09:44PM (#20856188)
It has marginally higher density; I didn't forget this benefit. The tradeoff is something like 5% more space vs much worse performance and many man-years rewriting filesystems.
Re:What Is Zoned Storage and the Zoned Storage Initiative? by mbjorling on Sunday September 01, 2019 @02:24AM (#20850788)
As SSDs get denser, moving to QLC/PLC, the number af writes to the same place on media gets to the low hundreds.

By using zones, the total amount of available host writes increases by 4-5x (when considering non-optimized file-systems). Technically the device write amplification is reduced from 4-5x to ~1x.