Every time society attaches a price tag to an unlimited resource like copies of software, we make ourselves poorer overall by minimizing our benefit from wealth that can't be used up or worn out. In my ideal world, software is developed as work for hire, because it's actually skilled labor that's scarce and needs to be rationed out by the economy. Doctors don't sell medicine, plumbers don't sell pipe, why should developers sell copies of binaries rather than hours of work?
Because selling copies is far more scalable and profitable?
The GPL proposes to give users that right. Since I am in that uncomfortable user position a lot, I am all for it.
For a perhaps overused metaphor, I wouldn't buy a car with the hood welded shut.
Care to explain your reasoning?
> The GPL is designed to ensure the maximum freedoms of developers.
That's why it explicitly prohibits you from using GPL'ed code under proprietary licenses.
No. If you intend to engage in an intelligent debate, you should, at least, educate yourself to a point you actually can.
> That it simultaneously destroys any hope that those same developers can enrich themselves by selling the software
You can always double-license it, MySQL-style. Again, GPL is not for the developers, but for the users. In your case, it's likely you use more software than you create, so, in the end, the GPL actually benefits you despite your own misgivings and misconceptions.
> I wouldn't be able to sell software
Why? What I can't have is a monopoly on the GPL'ed software I sell. OTOH, nobody can have a monopoly on GPL'ed software. And that's a very good thing for the users, who are sure they will have both the software and the technical means to maintain it on the unlikely event I am hit by a bus.
My reasoning is that the GPL is about what you can do with the code the program is based on. USERS don't do stuff with code. Programmers do stuff with code. A user is not going to take an annoying bug in your app and fix it, but (given guaranteed access to the source) a developer might.
> You can always double-license it, MySQL-style.
cough Indeed. uncough
They use it, they trust it works and they hire programmers to do stuff on their behalf.
> but (given guaranteed access to the source) a developer might.
Do you know of any other license that guarantees access to source from every downstream fork?
The GPL is designed to ensure the maximum freedoms of developers.
That it simultaneously destroys any hope that those same developers can enrich themselves by selling the software is supremely ironic, as it forces them to live as wage slaves under the whims of their corporate overlords. Thus they gain one sort of liberty but at the expense of giving up other economic freedoms.
Frankly if someone came up to me and said that in their ideal world I wouldn't be able to sell software or build my own software company, I'd want to burn them at the stake for heresy. Fortunately the world is big enough for everyone. :D