News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is learning to program inherently hard? by joe_the_user on Saturday January 08, 2011 @04:56PM (#2084071)
I would note that the author jumps between "teaching programming is hard", "programming is hard" and "learning programming is hard". None of these are equivalent statements about a field in general (even if they're all true here).

Still, it seems like in fact saying things about "programming" might also being inherently hard!

I mean, we can say that the halting problem is inherently but the halting problem doesn't reflect the day-to-day practices of the working programmer. Yet how do we characterize what does? The boundary between programming and using computers is fuzzy and given Church-Turing, just about defined activity can be encompassed in using a computer (a lot of machinists have become "programmers" of numerically controlled machines but this use is more similar to artists using Photoshop than software engineers using c++). One might argue that the advance of computer technology will create more and more professions which involve the high-level use of computers but won't be "programming as such" (spread-sheet use, UI design, etc).

By that token, if "real programming" is what's left when you've codified the other occupations, one could argue that it is inherently hard. But we're still a bit at the level of tautology.

There are no comments on this comment yet.