There is also the question of how a romantic relationship can impact a professional relationship. A manager needs to be able to reprimand their subordinates, and sometimes even fire them. Romantic relationships complicate those situations. It works the other way too -- sometimes romantic relationships need to end, and that might spill over into the workplace (see e.g. the reporting on [edited for correctness] Sergey's affair).
It should be blindingly obvious that managers and their subordinates should not have romantic relationships. There are countless problems, and almost no upside for any of the people involved.
There are other ways to deal with that though short of banning or moving people, eg adding additional scrutiny of decisions by an uninvolved third party and having objective decision making criteria for career related points (promotions, bonuses, pay rises, firings etc) where possible.
Unfair? What isn't?
>What if your boss was abusing you and you go to complain to HR and the HR person is having an affair with your boss ?
HR exists solely to create a paper trail that helps the company should you sue them. If you expect them to do anything beyond that, you are just setting yourself up for a disappointment.
You could replace affair with a friendship in all of your examples and it wouldn't change anything. Does it suck when promotions are handed out to friends rather than based on merit? Sure, but it doesn't mean we should ban socializing with colleagues.
I think it's right that there should be some protection against that.
Beyond that, favoritism from romance tends to be much stronger and far less rational than favoritism from friendship. Indeed, work friendships are even often formed on the basis of a mutual recognition of competence. Romantic friendships are usually based on factors utterly unrelated to performance at work.
What if your colleague is now promoted and people allege that it was unfair ?
What if they break up and end up ruining the working of the whole team ?
What if your boss was abusing you and you go to complain to HR and the HR person is having an affair with your boss ?
What if your colleague consented to having an affair but felt coerced because the boss had a lot of power over them ?
Would you allow such a thing to be rampant in your own company ? It’s understandable why companies would want to discourage it at the minimum.
Also the issues in the article are quite serious and go beyond having an affair