News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is there more to VLC's removal from the App Store? by mechanical_fish on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:51PM (#2083793)
Yeah, what a strategically brilliant move: fight DRM by removing one of the most popular and full-featured players of unencumbered content from the hands of users.

Because nothing sells DRM-free content like making it more difficult to play.

And it goes without saying that the sight of a single developer torpedoing a popular project over the objections of both other developers and users is an awesome commercial for open source.

Re:Is there more to VLC's removal from the App Store? by person on Saturday January 08, 2011 @03:31PM (#2083882)
If there is a problem with the license, pretending otherwise doesn't seem very sustainable to me. Shooting the messenger might make the mob feel better, but that doesn't make it justified.
Re:Is there more to VLC's removal from the App Store? by martythemaniak on Saturday January 08, 2011 @03:29PM (#2083874)
Both the GPL and VLC were around long before Apple's store. The developer contributed to a project that had a very clear, existing copyrights and Apple chose not to honour that. Simple as that.

And yes, seeing apple fanboys jump on this guy because he wants his rights honoured is pretty sickening.

Re:Is there more to VLC's removal from the App Store? by foljs on Saturday January 08, 2011 @04:52PM (#2084061)
You can have all the right in the world and still be an ahole.
Re:Is there more to VLC's removal from the App Store? by sid0 on Saturday January 08, 2011 @05:10PM (#2084099)
One man's asshole is another man's hero. Who are you to judge him?
Re:Is there more to VLC's removal from the App Store? by foljs on Sunday January 09, 2011 @08:25PM (#2087045)
Obviously the "one man" in your opening sentence. Duh!
Re:Is there more to VLC's removal from the App Store? by tygorius on Saturday January 08, 2011 @09:21PM (#2084607)
> a single developer torpedoing a popular project over the objections of both other developers and users

So, your point is that developers should only enforce their rights when it will be popular?

I was singularly unimpressed by the blog author's focus on blaming the developer for making things inconvenient for others. Well, insisting on your rights is quite often inconvenient for others. And it's not like it should be surprising. This sort of conflict was inevitable given the terms of the App Store and the GPL.

Re:Is there more to VLC's removal from the App Store? by sid0 on Saturday January 08, 2011 @05:08PM (#2084095)
And it goes without saying that the sight of a single developer torpedoing a popular project over the objections of both other developers and users is an awesome commercial for open source.

It doesn't seem like VLC requires copyright assignment. If it did then the maintainers could implicitly or explicitly relicense VLC for the app store. Since Remi holds the copyright to whatever source code he wrote, he has a right to see that the source code isn't used against his wishes. Maybe he has a philosophical objection to Apple or the app store. Maybe he's just doing it "for the lulz". Whatever it is, it's honestly none of anyone else's business.

And that article is terribly one-sided. The only facts that matter are that Remi holds the copyright to some of VLC's source code and that the app store ToS is possibly incompatible with the GPL. Anything else (motives, etc) is a value judgement.