News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by jakear on Thursday August 29, 2019 @07:41PM (#20834749)
“In most machine scoring states, any of the randomly selected essays with wide discrepancies between human and machine scores are referred to another human for review”.

And “between 5 to 20 percent” of essays are randomly selected for human review.

So the takeaway is that if you’re one of the 80-95% of (typically black or female) people who the machine scored dramatically lower, but are not selected for human review, your education future is systematically fucked and you have no knowledge of why or how to change it.

Absolutely reprehensible. Anyone involved in the creation or adoption of these systems should be ashamed.

Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by kazinator on Thursday August 29, 2019 @07:46PM (#20834771)
The thing is, you could be similarly screwed by a biased human whose grading is not checked by a less biased human.

At least the machines offer the following hope: even if unbiased humans are rare among paper-grading teachers, those humans can be used to train the machines, so then bias-free or lower-bias grading becomes more ubiquitous.

Basically, the system has the potential for systematically identifying and reducing systematic bias. A computer program can be retrained much more readily than nation-wide army of humans. Humans can be given a lecture on bias, and then they will just return to their ways.

Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by gibolt on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:03PM (#20834832)
AI has a lot more potential for bias than humans. It depends on the input data which is likely heavily biased based on other data set results like face detection. It will only amplify any small bias present in the data.
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by Spivak on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:18PM (#20834902)
It's amazing to see how the general opinion of CS people has completely shifted in the last few years from "algorithmic scoring is important in removing the bias from human graders" to the exact opposite.
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by kazinator on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:37PM (#20835005)
If we can quantify the bias in the machine, that gives us an opportunity to close the feedback loop and control the bias.

The bias comes from the human-generated training data in the first place; the machine isn't introducing its own. For instance, the machine has no inherent concept of disparaging someone's language because it's from an identifiable inner city dialect. If it picks up that bias, at least it will apply it consistently. When we investigate the machine, the machine will not know that it's being investigated and will not try to conceal its bias from us.

On the other hand, eliminating bias from humans basically means this: producing a new litter of small humans and teaching them better than their predecessors.

Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by gibolt on Friday August 30, 2019 @11:34AM (#20839589)
If...
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by Larrikin on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:30PM (#20834970)
That was the hope, but all the most effective methods suffer from data collection bias and the studies show that makes them worst than implicitly biased humans.
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by peteradio on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:37PM (#20835006)
It is important but its not ready.
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by solveit on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:13PM (#20834872)
So will humans. With AI, the model and training data are auditable and, if necessary, modifiable. You can't audit a person's life history and you can only really modify a grader by replacing them, and it's much less socially damaging to retrain a model than to fire an employee.

AI certainly has a lot of potential for bias, but claims that AI bias is somehow worse than good old human bias always seem shoddily supported (Note I'm not claiming it's untrue. Just that it's never been shown to my satisfaction, which is not surprising given how quickly AI is changing. It may well be true.)

Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by kazinator on Thursday August 29, 2019 @09:18PM (#20835194)
> but claims that AI bias is somehow worse than good old human bias always seem shoddily supported

Well, AI bias can combine sampling bias with human bias. Like say we train the AI with the output of only 10 human paper graders, all chosen from the same school district.

Due to the sampling bias, that data could create markedly more (or less!) bias than the entire population of human paper-graders.

The resulting AI will ideally mimic those 10 humans, though; it shouldn't show more bias than that group. If those 10 are flaring racists, and grade accordingly, the AI will be the same. (In fact, we hope that it will be the same, if the algorithm actually works in mimicking human grading.)

Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by IanSanders on Friday August 30, 2019 @04:29AM (#20836778)
>Anyone involved in the creation or adoption of these systems should be ashamed

That's the problem - there is seemingly no shame these days. People involved "saved time and money", got paid and that's it. "If I didn't do it someone else would" and all of that.

Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by sjg007 on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:09PM (#20834859)
Weapons of Math Destruction talks about this.
[dead]
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by mintplant on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:28PM (#20834964)
Did you read the article this thread is discussing? It cites multiple specific results wherein minority and female writers were underscored by the machine graders compared to human ones.
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by hydrox24 on Thursday August 29, 2019 @09:28PM (#20835245)
> It's quite funny how are some people manipulated to think that society and especially education is somehow biased against minorities or women when opposite is true

I think you have misunderstood the parent, who is asserting that the machines scoring these essays typically give lower scores to members of these demographics. This does not, by itself, mean the entire system is biased against those groups.

Whether or not the groups are, overall, systematically benefitted or harmed is not relevant to the injustice this article says exists.

Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by topologistics on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:31PM (#20834979)
The idea that black folks and females score dramatically lower on anything is a commonly held racist opinion that is foundational for the continuation of institutional oppression. When you assume the worst about people it ends up hindering their personal progress.
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by garmaine on Thursday August 29, 2019 @09:24PM (#20835228)
That's not what the article is saying, at all. There ARE general differences in style and word choice between minority groups or women and the average white male in writing. The corpus of training examples used in making this AI grader are at least biased towards the average white male. When the AI grades an essay harshly, it is not saying "this essay by a black woman is bad writing", it is saying "this essay differes from my training set by an aggregate score of ____", then sorts those results and (maybe) applies a curve.

An essay could be different from the reference standard because the standard is an example of good writing and the essay is not. Or it can be different because the author has a cultural, regional, gender, or developed background that imparts a different style than anything in the training corpus. Mistaking the two is very, very bad.

Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by shkkmo on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:49PM (#20835054)
They do when graded by a computer program as described in the article. Are you disputing the article's veracity? What is your point?
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by LeonB on Thursday August 29, 2019 @10:08PM (#20835427)
The links you provided don’t show what you claim.
Re:Flawed Algorithms Are Grading Millions of Students’ Essays by lonelappde on Thursday August 29, 2019 @09:59PM (#20835383)
That link talks about how black women are attending college in highest proportion due to extremely recent growth. It also says that despite their recently high educational attainment, black women are still underrepresented by a factor of 2 in private sector jobs, as compared to their college graduation rates.