That said, it's certainly possible to live in a simple, low-resource way without being disorderly and unclean. I think along the lines of those rural places with a whole bunch of shit strewn about the yard when I think of 'living like animals', as opposed to a small, simple cabin in the woods.
https://psmag.com/environment/opting-homesteading-matter-tod...
https://www.literallydarling.com/blog/2016/11/04/millennials...
Just because we got bigger houses and less polio in the same timeline doesn't mean those too things are correlated to the same cause. In my experience, most of the scientific researchers producing cures for disease and prolonging life aren't doing it for material wealth. There's a deeper drive to it than that.
Maybe the progress in healthcare proceeds against the tide of social forces. It probably does, considering doctors artificially limit the supply of doctors, precisely so they can buy bigger houses, fancier cars, and more jewelry.
It's estimated that Jonas Salk would have made $7 Billion if he'd patented the polio vaccine.
I believe if we are going to reverse the damage we have done to the planet, we have to invert our social reward structure. We should shame those who spend extravagantly and praise restraint.
I suppose it depends on how you interpret the parents "If we lived like they did". I don't think its reasonable to spin out a scenario where healthcare would be better, because all the elements of supplying healthcare become harder. I don't think it would necessarily be worse overall though.
They denigrate them because their lifestyle makes them uncomfortable.
It makes them uncomfortable because they are free in many ways that middle class people are not.
They are free of our social norms and they could earn a weeks income in a day selling wood.
It probably made them question their life choices and the fairness of the system.
I find it interesting how disrespectfully nose up folks talk about humble people like the Cedar Choppers, when if we all continued to live like they did, we wouldn't be in this climate mess we are in.
It's caring about possessions and extravagant homes (unfit for animals?) that has destroyed the planet for all animals.