Re:Which one will execute faster, if(flag==0) or if(0==flag)?
by xyzzyz on Saturday January 08, 2011 @05:43AM
(#2082816)
I use them conventionally -- it helps me avoid bugs like 'if(foo = 3)' instead of 'if(foo == 3)'. 'if(3 = foo)' just will not compile. The 'if(6.28 < theta)' is just a logical consequence.
Re:Which one will execute faster, if(flag==0) or if(0==flag)?
by Luyt on Monday January 10, 2011 @05:58PM
(#2090059)
My C/C++ compiler will give a warning on 'if (foo=3)'.
Python will throw a SyntaxError on 'if foo = 3:'.
Re:Which one will execute faster, if(flag==0) or if(0==flag)?
by daleharvey on Friday January 07, 2011 @11:45PM
(#2082251)
as someone else has mentioned they have been coined yoda conditions, which I love as a name.
Re:Which one will execute faster, if(flag==0) or if(0==flag)?
by cdavid on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:54AM
(#2082500)
OTOH, measuring this kind of things is quite hard - it is only a couple of cycles assuming the optimistic case, so smaller than most measurement methods overhead.
People often wrongly assume that you can just execute many times the thing in a loop, and compute the average, which is the wrong statistic (you want the min, not the average when measing the speed of something which has a fixed cost).
By itself, the question is pretty stupid - maybe that's what the interviewer was getting at ?
Re:Which one will execute faster, if(flag==0) or if(0==flag)?
by wnoise on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:04AM
(#2082428)
Isn't it interesting that x < y, y > x, !(x >= y), and !(y >= x) all express the same thing differently (barring NaNs)? Why should one of them be considered more "inside out" than another? Why does it make a difference if one is a constant rather than a variable? Does one of "x + 2" and "2 + x" seem inside-out as compared to the other? How about "2 * x" vs "x * 2"?
Re:Which one will execute faster, if(flag==0) or if(0==flag)?
by Luyt on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:16AM
(#2082436)
You're right. I think it's just what people are used to. Compare:
"If two gallons is less than the amount of gas in your tank, you should fill it up."
"If you have less than two gallons of gas left in your tank, you should fill it up."
In everyday speech, as well in mathematics, it is usual to state the variable first (what are we're going to compare) and then the amount to which it will be compared.
Re:Which one will execute faster, if(flag==0) or if(0==flag)?
by __david__ on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:58AM
(#2082610)
The first is especially awkward because you forgot to flip the < into a >. It should be, "If two gallons is greater than the amount of gas in your tank, you should fill it up."
Also, premature optimisation is the root of all evil ;-)
There is also an aesthetical side to it. Personally I find constructs like 'if (6.28 < theta) {...}' unpleasant to read. They look like thoughts turned inside out.