News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we skip Photoshop by josefresco on Tuesday June 03, 2008 @03:02PM (#208211)
Horrible advice from a company who has never lost their ass on a project when the client didn't like their HTML/CSS 'mockup'.

For a small project I spend 4-5 hours in Adobe Fireworks, then upon approval (hint: very important if your client doesn't worship you like 37signals) I build the pages out in real HTML/CSS/JS etc.

My sketch/mockup step is digital, I don't use dead trees.

Alaskamiller is right on, Photoshop is the wrong tool for the job.

Re:Why we skip Photoshop by ocskills on Tuesday June 03, 2008 @04:24PM (#208302)
I hear what you're saying with regard to clients, but I think you totally missed 37s' point. They're NOT saying "don't mockup at all". Rather, they are encouraging an interactive process with real and usable output that adapts more easily to collaboration and change. There is nothing you can do with Photoshop that you can't do with paper prototypes and follow-on HTML mockups.
Re:Why we skip Photoshop by nertzy on Wednesday June 04, 2008 @02:13AM (#208650)
I'd take that even further and say that instead of nothing, there's too much you can do with Photoshop that you can't with paper prototypes and HTML mockups.

The ability to do drop shadows on text and use all sorts of fonts and apply a motion blur and lens flare and opacity and all that doesn't translate well to the Web.

It's very frustrating as a Web developer to have someone send an over-Photoshopped mockup that won't work well as a functioning website.

Re:Why we skip Photoshop by henning on Tuesday June 03, 2008 @03:21PM (#208227)
Clients suck, film at 11.

They code HTML by hand because it's part of creating a domain language for the application - the interface drives the data model.

Re:Why we skip Photoshop by rrwhite on Tuesday June 03, 2008 @04:12PM (#208283)
It seems like your saying it takes you longer to do it in HTML/CSS than in Fireworks. They're saying that for them, like myself, that's not the case and thus you should skip the extra step or learn to do mockup html/css faster that you can justify skipping PS.
Re:Why we skip Photoshop by davidw on Tuesday June 03, 2008 @04:30PM (#208310)
> Horrible advice from a company who has never lost their ass on a project when the client didn't like their HTML/CSS 'mockup'.

Maybe what you should take away from this is that it's better to do your own thing, rather than be a slave to clients.

Re:Why we skip Photoshop by sgoraya on Tuesday June 03, 2008 @06:46PM (#208411)
>Maybe what you should take away from this is that it's better to do your own thing, rather than be a slave to clients.

What the..? Do your own thing instead of listening to your clients huh? Sounds like bread winning advice!

Sarcasm aside, I agree to a certain degree with the parent post - We do work for individual clients and design selection is their choice, since, drumroll, thats what they are paying us for! You can definitely help them out with suggestions, but ultimately your job is to make the client happy - If you are running your own company (or consulting) servicing clients, I'd say that is doing your own thing.

Re:Why we skip Photoshop by davidw on Wednesday June 04, 2008 @03:27AM (#208680)
> What the..? Do your own thing instead of listening to your clients huh? Sounds like bread winning advice!

Clients != Customers, which was precisely my point. Clients and consulting is a linear growth curve, and difficult to grow into much of a business: add more clients and you have to add more people to do work for them. Customers and products (ala 37signals) means a hyper-linear growth curve, and a nice business.

A "startup" as most people mean it here is not a consulting shop. Clearly, if you are a consulting shop, you need to listen to your clients.