News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by krastanov on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @02:33PM (#20813002)
I can agree with you that it might be a more productive fast way to fix some of the issues, but the fact is that racism still affects even the well-off people of color. Maternal deaths related to birth are a recently studied example, as is upward/downward social mobility among the well-off.
Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by SamReidHughes on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @02:38PM (#20813062)
Such studies aren't capable of determining that "racism" is the cause.
Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by Miner49er on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:27PM (#20813531)
What else could be a cause?
Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by pacala on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:53PM (#20813792)
This is a very divisive topic, for which we have strong cultural taboos and entrenched polarisation. I have yet to see shared explorations in search for the truth, where points from both sides of the debate are treated as coming from a place of good intentions. Every mistake, and there will be mistakes, genuine or perceived, will likely be exploited at the maximum, and possibly will devolve in invectives or worse. Furthermore, it is a complex topic where there may be a superposition of many causes, and teasing out the causes and their respective relative weights, by necessity, will be beyond what HN format can possibly support.

Case in point, "racism". Implying, among other things, KKK and lynchings. Would you submit that the root cause for differentials in college-level education attainment in 2019 between racial groups is endemic lynchings? If not, I would kindly submit that we need a different word to start a conversation.

Edit: Small rephrase to hopefully address u/krastanov concerns.

Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by krastanov on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @04:00PM (#20813861)
I completely agreed with you until you wrote:

> Case in point, "racism". Implying KKK and lynchings.

Is there really a group of people that participate in intellectually honest debates that actually think the use of the word "racism" in 2019 implies "KKK and lynching"!? This sounds incredibly out of proportion to me - yes, KKK/lynching are near one of the extremes of the spectrum of racism, but it is (or used to be) incredibly far from the main realization of racism today.

Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by krastanov on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:31PM (#20813571)
While I very much disagree with that idea because it has been disproven plenty of times, the usual "not racism" explanation that people suggest is some inherent difference between ethnicities unrelated to historical subjugation or current policies. At this point I take the proponents of such "not racism" explanations as willfully ignorant implicit racists at best.
Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by mises on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @05:32PM (#20814598)
"If you don't agree with me, you're a willfully ignorant implicit racist."

Not a productive remark; painting all who disagree with you as "racists" devalues the legitimate use of the term and prevents honest discourse.

Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by nathanasmith on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @07:36AM (#20818738)
You are starting with your conclusion already in mind.
Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by SamReidHughes on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @04:20PM (#20814044)
The inverse of poor immigrants' children having great upwards mobility. More people being in a high income bracket because of circumstance, without repeatable performance in the next generation. You'll see the same thing with the demographic of bitcoin millionaires.

In the case of maternal deaths, obviously obesity, diet, drug use, etc, are variables. And simple biological propensity to survive childbirth. And the physiology of Africans, let alone the complexities of X% African + (100-X)% Anglo physiology, being harder to deal with.

Re:College Board Drops Plans for SAT Student Adversity Score by marcusverus on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @05:07PM (#20814415)
What studies attribute racial differences in maternal mortality to racism?