News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by YeGoblynQueenne on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @11:43AM (#20810834)
I don't understand - what is the dumb meme? The link of high cholesterol to heart disease seems to be very well supported by numerous studies, and so are the benefits of reducing high LDL with diet or medication (statins).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cholesterol#Hypercholesterolem...

According to the lipid hypothesis, elevated levels of cholesterol in the blood lead to atherosclerosis which may increase the risk of heart attack, stroke, and peripheral vascular disease. Since higher blood LDL – especially higher LDL concentrations and smaller LDL particle size – contributes to this process more than the cholesterol content of the HDL particles,[68] LDL particles are often termed "bad cholesterol". High concentrations of functional HDL, which can remove cholesterol from cells and atheromas, offer protection and are commonly referred to as "good cholesterol". These balances are mostly genetically determined, but can be changed by body composition, medications, diet,[69] and other factors.[70] A 2007 study demonstrated that blood total cholesterol levels have an exponential effect on cardiovascular and total mortality, with the association more pronounced in younger subjects. Because cardiovascular disease is relatively rare in the younger population, the impact of high cholesterol on health is larger in older people.[71]

Elevated levels of the lipoprotein fractions, LDL, IDL and VLDL, rather than the total cholesterol level, correlate with the extent and progress of atherosclerosis.[72] Conversely, the total cholesterol can be within normal limits, yet be made up primarily of small LDL and small HDL particles, under which conditions atheroma growth rates are high. A post hoc analysis of the IDEAL and the EPIC prospective studies found an association between high levels of HDL cholesterol (adjusted for apolipoprotein A-I and apolipoprotein B) and increased risk of cardiovascular disease, casting doubt on the cardioprotective role of "good cholesterol".[73][74]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypercholesterolemia#Diagnosis

Higher levels of total cholesterol increase the risk of cardiovascular disease, particularly coronary heart disease.[33] Levels of LDL or non-HDL cholesterol both predict future coronary heart disease; which is the better predictor is disputed.[34] High levels of small dense LDL may be particularly adverse, although measurement of small dense LDL is not advocated for risk prediction.[34]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lipid_hypothesis

The lipid hypothesis (also known as the cholesterol hypothesis) is a medical theory postulating a link between blood cholesterol levels and occurrence of heart disease. A summary from 1976 described it as: "measures used to lower the plasma lipids in patients with hyperlipidemia will lead to reductions in new events of coronary heart disease".[1] Or, more concisely, "decreasing blood cholesterol... significantly reduces coronary heart disease".[2]

An accumulation of evidence has led to the acceptance of the lipid hypothesis by most of the medical community.[3]

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by dmwallin on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @11:56AM (#20811043)
This is all true but missing one important fact. Dietary cholesterol doesn't turn directly into blood cholesterol. It makes sense why this became a common misconception, but the actual physiological mechanics of this are more complex.

https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/what-should-you...

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by ralusek on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:06PM (#20811160)
I don't actually hear people talk about cholesterol in food, though. They almost always mean high in animal fat, which my understanding is that this then results in higher LDL in the bloodstream.
Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by scottlocklin on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:02PM (#20811111)
It's more complicated than that, apparently.

https://peterattiamd.com/the-straight-dope-on-cholesterol-pa...

I've trudged through all parts of his explanations; worth it if you're interested in lipidology, but this contains adequate punchlines to be helpful. TLDR we're probably measuring the wrong thing. And stop eating sugar. Oh yeah, and eating cholesterol is irrelevant.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by virtuallynathan on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:45PM (#20811693)
My favorite bit in this, is when he gets to the really important part about how, precisely, lipoproteins cause disease, the explanation is that it "illegally parks"

"So what drives an LDL particle to do something as sinister as to leave the waterway (i.e., the bloodstream) and “illegally” try to park at a dock (i.e., behind an endothelial cell)? Well, it is a gradient driven process which is why particle number is the key driving parameter."

Except it isn't gradient driven, because it's an active process of transcytosis...

There's just so many holes in the lipid hypothesis.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by scottlocklin on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @01:14PM (#20812105)
It's an uncomfortable realization when you first figure out how much of modern "medical wisdom" is based on incomplete understanding, bad stats, marketing crapola from food and drug manufacturers, and weird NGO groups trying to justify their existence.

Modern medicine is really good at trauma care, and certainly the discovery of vitamins, antibiotics and hand washing are good ideas; otherwise, I'm not so sure!

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by YeGoblynQueenne on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:17PM (#20813443)
Not to be rude to you or fellow HN users, but between a comment on HN and "modern 'medical wisdom'" I think I'll choose the latter every time, just on the basis that a comment on HN is not as likely to be correct as "modern 'medical wisdom'".

Also, just as a bit of pattern matching that may be completely off, but I haven't heard the most accurate things from people who challenge medical wisdom with scare quotes. Doctors study those things for a living. I don't know why people think they know best because they can read ncbi.gov.

But- I'll listen more carefully if the person commenting is a doctor who works with patients day-in, day-out. That kind of experience still counts for something, flawed as subjective judgements may be.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by scottlocklin on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @04:28PM (#20814108)
> Doctors study those things for a living. I don't know why people think they know best because they can read ncbi.gov.

See, that's just the thing: Doctors absolutely do not study this sort of thing for a living. Researchers do. That's why I linked you to a researcher, rather than something written by the guy I see when I need antibiotics or to get a mole checked out.

I ain't asking you to take my word for it: I provided you a link to a guy who really does study this sort of thing for a living. And he says ... it's really complicated, and the standard advice/treatments are probably baloney. Maybe he's wrong! Doesn't look that way though.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by YeGoblynQueenne on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @06:36PM (#20815146)
Doctors have to study to become doctors and then they practice medicine every day. I expect, if someone has a reliable intuition about how things like cholesterol work out in practice, that's a doctor who has to treat patients every day.

In fact, in this particular kind of knowledge (of how test results correlate with various outcomes) I would trust a doctor's intuition, formed by long experience, more than I'd trust data and research results.

Kind of nonplussed that you'd diss doctors as "the guy I see when I need antibiotics or to get a mole checked out". Do you really think what doctors do is so simple?

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by scottlocklin on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @07:42PM (#20815504)
I taught medical students in a top-5 medical school and know how the sausage got made.

They're great at the things I listed: trauma care, treatment of acute conditions, the concept of vitamins and use of antibiotics. For stuff involving chronic conditions, or even nutrition advice, they appear to be worse than useless.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @06:09AM (#20818337)
This is not my experience. My experience is that- it's a mixed bag.

I ... don't like to discuss personal medical details online of course. But, I recently had a dry cough that didn't go away after many months and I was obviously shitting bricks (though I don't smoke) so I went to my GP. She prescribed ...antacids. I left frustrated, and incomprehending, but of course she knows I have an ulcer, and it seems that the acid coming up my esophagus is irritating my vocal cords.

Note that she didn't sit down at her computer and google my symptoms or anything like that. Our meeting took all of 5 minutes (stupid NHS guidelines...) which is btw why she had no time to explain and I had to look up things myself. But she got it right. In 5 minutes time and under the pressure of a couple dozen other patients in the waiting room. It reminded me of stories about machine learning systems modelling some complex dataset and coming up with surprising results that initially leave researchers bewildered, until digging a bit reveals the accuracy of the model.

Perhaps teaching medical students rather than practicing yourself is skewing your view a bit (you didn't say you are actually a doctor though)? I have respect for doctors' intuition, but maybe, on my part, I'm just impressed because of my own lack of knowledge.

On the other hand, another doctor I see for a chronic condition I don't want to discuss online is completely useless and has all the intuition and skill of a boiled piece of cabbage. But that's not a tale for HN.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by scottlocklin on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:25PM (#20821275)
I'm not a doctor of medicine; my course (experimental physics methods; basically something where they learn something approximating general diagnosis skills) was a weeder for medical students.

I am in abundant agreement with you that some doctors are amazing and some are cabbage brained imbeciles. The point I'm trying to make here is that for squishy complex chronic conditions like hyperlipidemia, I don't think even the very good ones are well equipped to know what they're talking about unless they spend a lot of time reviewing the literature (and even then, if they act on it, they may be voiding their malpractice insurance terms among other things). T-tests on the differences in outcomes are fairly difficult to interpret for researchers; it's impossible to eyeball and make sense of it with the samples a GP is exposed to. There's all kinds of confounding bias as well; they don't see people who don't go to the doctor, have the condition (such as it is) and do fine without any intervention. As such, they basically stick with the prevailing ideology. And they get this ideology wrong all the time. It's not their fault; it's just how the world works. For myself, I build in a discount term for doctor advice based on what the issue is. Basically if doctors are provably good at treating an illness; I will shut my cake hole and obey. If they're not, I'm at least going to dig into the literature.

FWIIW an anecdote for you: Andy Sessler, the former director of LBNL developed a brain tumor while running the place. He had access to the very best treatment in the world, including the Bevatron proton bombardment technique, but he chose to adopt some kind of macrobiotic diet and take up running (founding the LBNL runaround in the process). I think the tumors eventually killed him; 35 years after he was diagnosed. I didn't know him beyond seeing him around at seminars and runarounds and such, but I assume his gamble was based on a deep understanding of how the stats on the disease treatments played out.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday August 29, 2019 @06:13PM (#20834236)
Thanks for a good conversation :)
Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by virtuallynathan on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @06:16PM (#20814984)
Not a doctor, sorry :)

I have, however, spent many many hours over the last year reading all of the research I can find on the lipid hypothesis, metabolism, lipoproteins, nutrition, etc. I started a podcast, and have started chatting to researchers, doctors, etc.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @06:20AM (#20818391)
>> Not a doctor, sorry :)

No matter. Sorry if my comment comes across as a bit stand-offish.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by holbrad on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @02:30PM (#20812951)
Your drastically oversimplifying LDL's role in disease.

High LDL is a very weak predictor. This has been known since the Framingham study. Looking at a combination of LDL, HDL and trigs is a much better predictor.

High LDL in combination with low trigs and high HDL, is actually protective (Not a risk factor at all)

The Jeppesen Study (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11176761)

the Framingham Offspring study(https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/full/10.1161/CIRCOUTCOMES.11...)

How oxidised the LDL particles are is really the major metric that matters. From looking at cell cultures we know that high levels of non-oxidised LDL have no atherosclerotic properties inherently. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-13-0620-4_...

Personally its my opinion that the lipid hypothesis is essentially junk. The level of LDL is a major distraction, from root issues such as inflammation, oxidation stress and diabetes, which are caused mostly by sugar and refined carbohydrates consumption.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by YeGoblynQueenne on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:23PM (#20813495)
>> Personally its my opinion that the lipid hypothesis is essentially junk.

OK, but this seems to be just your opinion and contrary to what experts (doctors, public health bodies, etc) advise.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by virtuallynathan on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @06:27PM (#20815073)
I'll thrown in my 2c that is really is junk.

Decent overview of some of the flaws: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5969815/ https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17512433.2018.1...

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by AstralStorm on Thursday August 29, 2019 @05:03AM (#20827897)
Doctors are not experts in this, nor are public bodies. Endocrinology researchers are...

It's really still an open field. New findings take almost a generation (20 years) to propagate to run off the mill doctors, slightly faster to specialists. And public bodies are slow as molasses in comparison, some still pushing advice from 1950s.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by AstralStorm on Thursday August 29, 2019 @07:25AM (#20828485)
Sorry about self reply, edit was not available.

Here's a decent paper on the matter of getting research into practice:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3241518/

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by maximente on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @11:52AM (#20810981)
you're redirecting to a similar but unrelated claim. the claim under scrutiny is:

> eating cholesterol-rich food raises blood levels of cholesterol and damages the heart

not whether or not high cholesterol to heart disease generally is impactful. that's an important distinction, and what you've posted here isn't evidence for or against that.

Re:Crows love cheeseburgers and are getting high cholesterol by YeGoblynQueenne on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:14PM (#20813409)
I asked the OP to clarify, because I think they are trying to make both points: that cholesterol in food does not affect cholesterol in blood and that high cholesterol (of X kind) does not affect the risk of disease.

The way I understand it, cholesterol in food is correlated with cholesterol in blood, it's just that thee are other factors that may be more important, like genetics. Well, genetics.