That would be true if Musk had owned SolarCity but not been CEO of Tesla: puffery short of actual fraud would be fine. As Tesla CEO, though, Musk has a fiduciary duty to Tesla shareholders, which means his (enforceable, legal) obligation is greater than just avoiding outright fraud.
If the arguments and timelines were knowingly dishonest, then that's fraud. Hence the lawsuit.
> Unless they were given tampered numbers or false factual information, Musk could oversell SolarCity prospects six ways from Sunday and they can't do anything about it.
If you release a fake product on stage and announce timelines you know there is no possibility of meeting, then yeah, there are a lot of legal ramifications to that. Especially given a case where there are so many personal financial entanglements.
Well, if the arguments at the time were good enough to convince them, sucks to be them. What are they gonna do?
Unless they were given tampered numbers or false factual information, Musk could oversell SolarCity prospects six ways from Sunday and they can't do anything about it.