Still, I often find it quite useful advice even for today's projects, where people commonly assume that they can put a late project back on track by adding people to it, and that by doubling the staff, the product will be produced twice as fast.
I still hold that
1.) That book is still one of the most relevant books I've seen lately (which might be scaring, I haven't made up my mind yet)
2.) While he might not have (or at least not include) data, he argues hos case well, and while I wouldn't bet money on experiments to follow his smooth curve I would be willing to bet (a small amount of) money that for non-trivial software his ideas would still result in better estimates than one that accepts "man-months" as a unit of progress.
And for those that haven't read the book yet it might be worth noting that while some people might find the book quotable more or less from cover to cover there is also a number of observations to be made that takes a full reading to realize. Here is one I'd like to point out:
Some quotes from the book might leave one thinking that he says programming cannot be scaled. I'd say the opposite is true, he just argues that it must be done in a thoughtful way instead of by mindlessly adding people to the project.
hyperpallium's original message, the one that started this thread is a feeble attempt at legitimizing the blog post by comparing it to a bunch of unrelated and generally appreciated things.
I am not a native speaker so I just looked up the phrase you seem to point to and the two first definitions says it means:
- Very difficult for one to comprehend or do.
- not something that I can understand
Am I missing something here?
Besides, I feel you moved the goal posts early on. I replied to you talking about the whole book, you replied with a single example.
Please let me know if I've missed something.
It's the implication my conclusion was foolish; but if you intended no insult, that's good enough for me.
You are correct that chapter two lacks supporting evidence. And that's a problem for the book, it doesn't mean it's ok to omit data everywhere now.