Re:Shipping containers of Li-ion batteries in the power grid
by yardie on Friday January 07, 2011 @11:28AM
(#2079973)
Flywheel technology were an area of research over a decade ago when battery research was still in its infancy. IIRC, GM had an electric car concept that had a huge fly wheel behind the cabin. But your options were slow, heavy (thus inefficient) flywheels or light, fast flywheels. And by fast I mean 100,000 RPM. At those speeds they were using Kevlar to keep it from flying apart, making it impractical because of the price of kevlar.
Re:Shipping containers of Li-ion batteries in the power grid
by coryrc on Friday January 07, 2011 @02:47PM
(#2080862)
Nickel is not a cheap metal and NiFe batteries are not efficient[1]. Nickel is much more damaging to the environment to extract.
LiFePO4 batteries have lifetimes exceeding 15 years (no one really knows how long yet -- they were invented in 1996). Their efficiency is well above 90%. Its raw material costs are less than NiFe.
Re:Shipping containers of Li-ion batteries in the power grid
by AaronM on Friday January 07, 2011 @11:41AM
(#2080014)
At the last company I worked for, which was a manufacturing facility. They installed a giant flywheel as a line conditioning device. (We manufactured NAS, and it is terribly costly when a power outage interrupts 5 days worth of testing forcing you to start over). I think it gave us about 17-18 seconds of power, in the event of any brief interruptions in power (Most of the outages we received were 1-2 seconds in length)
Re:Shipping containers of Li-ion batteries in the power grid
by aristus on Friday January 07, 2011 @04:45PM
(#2081251)
Some datacenters (eg the Miami IPX/NAP) use flywheels the size of large trucks to provide failover until the generators kick in. They are seriously scary machines up close.
Re:Shipping containers of Li-ion batteries in the power grid
by khafra on Friday January 07, 2011 @11:18AM
(#2079934)
Perhaps safety issues[1]?
Re:Shipping containers of Li-ion batteries in the power grid
by stcredzero on Friday January 07, 2011 @11:24AM
(#2079958)
Flywheel safety isn't such a big deal if you can bury the flywheel chamber in your backyard. Decades ago, there were fiberglass flywheels whose fibers simply unraveled when they failed, becoming a mass of very hot fuzz.
Re:Shipping containers of Li-ion batteries in the power grid
by Symmetry on Friday January 07, 2011 @12:07PM
(#2080114)
If you're doing these on an industrial scale a liquid salt battery might be worth while.
Re:Shipping containers of Li-ion batteries in the power grid
by jpitz on Friday January 07, 2011 @12:31PM
(#2080213)
Are you referring to the sodium sulfur batteries that NGK makes?
Wind and solar plants “introduce some additional variability that you don’t have with traditional thermal units,’’ Mr. Zaharuncik said. With a system that has a lot of renewable energy generators, he explained, “you need some other kind of resource that complements it. ‘’
I'm surprised that flywheels aren't a bigger deal because of wind and solar power. Why doesn't someone make a flywheel unit the size of a major appliance, incorporating inverters and regulating hardware, for home wind and solar?