Re:Mobile NixOS: The Present and the Future
by kstenerud on Saturday August 24, 2019 @05:22PM
(#20789795)
To me this sounds absolutely insane. Package managers that work in a couple of megabytes of ram is a solved problem. How can this be unsolvable?
Re:Mobile NixOS: The Present and the Future
by Filligree on Sunday August 25, 2019 @10:41AM
(#20793239)
It's not really the package-building process that takes tons of RAM. It's the OS-building process, where it pulls everything necessary to describe the current state of your machine into RAM, simultaneously.
This typically means several hundred packages at least, plus a lot of code that's not as easily classifiable as "packages". The config file generators are written in the same language.
Other operating systems punt on the challenge; there's no equivalent in e.g. Debian.
Re:Mobile NixOS: The Present and the Future
by kstenerud on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:01PM
(#20795162)
I get that, but it ran out of ram on a machine with 2gb of ram. Even if there were 10 million things to keep track of, that's 200 bytes per thing!
If we're talking about a file system with 100,000 files, that's 20 kb of metadata per file. Actually, more than that because it exhausted the ram.
Those numbers just don't add up.
Of course knowing why it happens didn't make it less frustrating, but it's hard to fix. What you can do is build your system remotely, on a more capable machine, perhaps with nixos-rebuild --target-host.
(That's a shell script, and fairly readable.)