News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by wsxcde on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:29AM (#20776387)
If you are seriously concerned about climate change, pressure your government to impose a large tax on beef and pay the proceeds from that tax directly to the people living in the amazon basin. That will incentivize them against deforestation.

Expecting poor people to voluntarily give up on the opportunity to make money because you are threatened about your children's future but can't even be arsed to reduce your own consumption of beef is wishful thinking at best.

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by esailija on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:55AM (#20776540)
Every "wallet voter" is in a kind of "prisoner's dilemma" with each other where it won't do anything if they stop unless everyone else stops too. But if everyone else stops then they can continue. Everoyne is aiming to be the one who can continue while everyone else stops thus nothing happens. Every collective downside of any consumption (and because of requirements for infinite growth there is always collective downside no matter what) will always go away if someone is the only one doing it.

So you cannot see or understand the system by looking at an individual. System that divides people into making rational individual decisions (called free market economy) without any real way to conspire co-operation is always going to result in something that is irrational for everyone as a whole. Everyone has to "defect" and for every person you convince against their self-interest to "co-operate" there will be 10 more "defecting". If you want best possible overall result you need entirely different system like centrally planned economy which for example walmart and amazon already uses.

If you attempt to fix the system instead changing it entirely you will just end up making it worse because of regulatory capture. The fault I described cannot be fixed because it would be contradictory to the very foundation, so instead of actually fixing anything it will make the system even more unfair and perverted.

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by tempguy9999 on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:09AM (#20776645)
Not everyone defects, and your conclusion that "regulatory capture" is inevitable, and that us little people can do nothing, is toxic. Both are wrong.

I've spent years of my life trying to change things but it is defeatists like you that are part of the problem - spreading "we're fucked anyway" memes is corrosive because it induces the exact attitude and behaviour you say will happen.

Let me be clear, if the world dies we die with it and you die too - got it? So please get off your butt, stop trying to look so worldly-wise, and do something. I know, I know, it takes more effort than posting on HN. Tricky, that.

[dead]
Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by dgellow on Friday August 23, 2019 @09:01AM (#20777041)
> Well more specifically either capitalism ends or the world ends.

Let's say capitalism ends right now without destabilizing the entire world (so no post apocalyptic scenario where only a few million survive). What would be a system that doesn't result in the "world as we know it" ending in the coming centuries? You would still have to deal with the current state of the environment and the current population. People will still be the same persons they are now, who wants to eat meat, over-consume, close their eyes when an issue doesn't concern them directly. Or do you see it in a different way?

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by esailija on Friday August 23, 2019 @10:10AM (#20777780)
> What would be a system that doesn't result in the "world as we know it" ending in the coming centuries?

Well like I said in my OP you'd need to have economy entirely based on planning around needs and environment as opposed to private profits.

> People will still be the same persons they are now, who wants to eat meat, over-consume, close their eyes when an issue doesn't concern them directly. Or do you see it in a different way?

It's hard to tell what people are "naturally" when they are forced to live under a system that requires those traits in order to function and perpetuate itself. If you remove overconsumption and individualism a capitalist economy will collapse, then it is most likely not a coincidence that people are like that in a capitalist economy and not their "true" nature.

If the system is even going to be changed it's going to be because critical mass of people have recognized the need to change it (not suddenly overnight) which implies they are no longer indoctrinated to overconsume and see the world in individualistic way and have assumed other ideologies that are needed to support and perpetuate the new system.

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by wsxcde on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:57AM (#20777008)
That's why I said you need to get laws passed making beef consumption extremely expensive. Individual acts of voting with your wallet are unlikely to succeed.
Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by tanto on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:42AM (#20776458)
Wouldn't that incentivize them to sell more cattle to create more tax income and in return more proceeds to them? Also you are saying

> people living in the amazon basin

are the ones producing all the beef or rather some big land lords?

I concur with the taxation but not paying the money to some other country - rather invest in alternatives.

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by wsxcde on Friday August 23, 2019 @09:00AM (#20777031)
As the article says, the Amazon rain forest supplies 20% of the world's oxygen. We all need it. If we won't do what it takes to prevent the people there from killing it, we will all get exactly what we deserve.

It might helpful to introspect on why you'd rather have the money spent on one side of an imaginary line the ground rather than another.

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by dangoor on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:42AM (#20776459)
> If you are seriously concerned about climate change, pressure your government to impose a large tax on beef and pay the proceeds from that tax directly to the people living in the amazon basin. That will incentivize them against deforestation.

But if the income they're receiving is coming from a tax on beef, wouldn't they want to produce more?

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by mc32 on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:00AM (#20776576)
Presumably the tax would make beef unpalatable to the wallet driving people to choose alternatives like chicken or lamb.
Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by yodsanklai on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:57AM (#20776555)
> If you are seriously concerned about climate change, pressure your government to impose a large tax on beef

Why not, but there are so many factors contributing to climate change that it's "suspicious" when people target one specific thing. It's quite difficult to be heard. Why should I renounce to eat beef, while other people have the right to have 3 kids, or to drive a SUV, or to fly to the other side of the world.

If it was possible, it would be best to integrate the cost of externalities in what we consume, so that everyone can choose to sacrifice what they value less. But maybe if we really had to pay for externalities, they wouldn't much that we could still afford.

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by justaguyhere on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:00AM (#20776575)
People love meat. I've had discussions with (otherwise) intelligent and responsible people - they suddenly turn irrational and irresponsible when talking about the amount of meat they consume and its shitty effects on everything.

It is going to be really difficult to convince people to consume less meat, increase tax on meat etc.

Not saying we shouldn't try, but it is a tough problem to take on.

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by rad_gruchalski on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:42AM (#20776463)
> If you are seriously concerned about climate change, pressure your government to impose a large tax on beef and pay the proceeds from that tax directly to the people living in the amazon basin. That will incentivize them against deforestation.

Wouldn’t this incentivise beef production? They would be indirectly paid for beef. Or am I reading this wrong?

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by PeterStuer on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:04AM (#20776598)
You really think ail deforestation is driven by the poor people, and not by the Brazilian meat packing corporations JBS, BRF, Marfrig and Minerva? Slavery is still very widespread in the meat-packing industry in the region, I do not think the 'poor' have much agency in this<
Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by glogla on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:48AM (#20776501)
Beef is like 2 % of humanity's emissions. Gasoline-based transportation and electricity (mostly from coal power plants) are together like 60 %.

It's obvious which one we need to focus on. Stop it with the beef already. We need data driven approach. We really really don't need hysteria based approach where something (like beef) is declared sinful.

(see https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emis...)

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by kdmccormick on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:55AM (#20776543)
Regardless of emissions, beef production is contributing to this specific problem. From the article:

> Much of the deforestation binge is being driven by farming pressure: The Amazon basin is the largest exporter of beef in the world, with about 200 million heads of cattle. And all those cows need a lot of space to spread out.

Did you not read before telling us we need a "data-driven approach"?

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by jdietrich on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:00AM (#20776574)
>Beef is like 2 % of humanity's emissions.

Methane emissions from beef cattle account for about 2% of GHG potential. Tropical deforestation contributes to about 10% of our climate impact, most of which is driven by beef farming. There are also significant non-climate impacts of deforestation in terms of biodiversity.

Beef is a big deal. It's not the biggest deal, but it's one of many things we need to address. Electricity generation and transport are being rapidly decarbonized thanks to new technology, but there's no technological replacement for old-growth rainforest. We can generate electricity with PV panels, we can run a car or a ship on batteries, but we don't have any sustainable option for things like jet aviation and beef; for the foreseeable future, the only option is to drastically reduce our consumption.

https://www.ucsusa.org/global-warming/stop-deforestation/bee...

Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by prawn on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:56AM (#20776551)
Isn't that more relevant to a general climate argument than one about the world's ecological heartland being cleared with fire to raise cattle? And as an individual, isn't it possible to make small steps without huge sacrifices on both fronts?
Re:Why the Amazon Is on Fire by adrianN on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:55AM (#20776544)
Beef is a large part of the reason why the Amazon is cleared for land.