Having a great touch screen does not rule out also having great buttons.
I don't know how long your test drive was but you may have missed that there are plenty of physical controls in the S, including buttons, that cover most functionality.
I don't know how long your test drive was but you may have missed that there are plenty of physical controls in the S, including buttons, that cover most functionality.
But they're still not as good as physical buttons, because they are impossible to control without looking at them.