News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things to Know About GNU Readline by aidenn0 on Thursday August 22, 2019 @07:39PM (#20773376)
Except clisp is quite useful without readline; cmucl (a contemporary lisp implementation) lacked any readline support.

Extending this, if someone made an API compatible BSD licensed readline clone, and the configure script will link with either that or the GNU readline, depending on what is in the system, would that still need to be GPL'd?

clisp itself ended up being moot because the author was happy to use the GPL and if they hadn't they could have just removed the readline support, but it is an interesting corner case of the law.

Re:Things to Know About GNU Readline by dragonwriter on Thursday August 22, 2019 @07:43PM (#20773404)
> Extending this, if someone made an API compatible BSD licensed readline clone

If APIs are protected by copyright, such a clone could be a copyright violation (depends on how fair use analysis applies.)

So, wait on appeals to be exhausted in Oracle v. Google to have a clue on the answer.

Re:Things to Know About GNU Readline by kazinator on Thursday August 22, 2019 @08:54PM (#20773745)
If API's are protected by copyright, and GNU takes action on such a thing, then that would be very hypocritical, giving all the proprietary API's cloned in GPL-ed software, including GNU projects.