>The actual problem the whole idea is solving is a revolutionary improvement.
Last I checked, this was a solved problem in Ubuntu. What makes it revolutionary now that Apple's done it?Come on, man, it's a Linux Distro – how many of our moms are installing those?
Plus there's the whole easy monetization thing for developers.
This is like saying Dropbox's functionality was a solved problem thanks to rsync.
Apple's store is no revolution in my book, far from it, but at least they put that Amazon One-click patent to good use and made the process easy.
But there's still lots of polish that it lacks.
It puts every app in the dock. What happens when someone wants to remove the app and tries to do so by dragging it off the dock?
The app still resides in the Applications folder but the user thinks it's gone. Now if he wants to download it again and goes back to the App Store the app is still marked as 'Installed' even though he thinks it's gone.
If he knows to look in the Applications folder and then tries to drag it to the trash, you get a UAC dialog asking for the root password.
So, they've partially solved the App install experience but not fully. The interface still has rough edges, which I'm sure they may eventually get right.
The "interface" problem is not custom controls or back buttons. The interface problem is installing software. That's the interface most average people stumble on. That's where computers suck.
So yeah, some of the UI in the Mac App Store app feels a bit off, but the stuff that matters - one click install of great apps onto your Mac - works beautifully. That's the interface triumph.