News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by sev on Thursday January 06, 2011 @03:44PM (#2077075)
> He answered, almost without thought, “Because that’s the only thing that will make you uncomfortable.

I think this article is well written, albeit a little extreme with some of it's points. The behavior of the man the author had anal sex with is obviously not the norm, and yet she uses the event as a way to describe the norm.

Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by jtbigwoo on Thursday January 06, 2011 @04:10PM (#2077193)
Her anecdote doesn't support her case. It seems clear that the guy was taking out his post-breakup frustrations on Ms. Vargas-Cooper. He may normally be a decent, caring person who just tried to get back in the dating pool too soon. Punishing a rebound girl/boy for the sins of the previous girl/boy is not something that either gender has a monopoly on.
Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by erikpukinskis on Thursday January 06, 2011 @03:55PM (#2077125)
She described his behavior, asking to make her uncomfortable, as uncommonly honest, so she agrees with you it's not the norm. I think her point is that the underlying desire is the norm, while the open and respectful request for consent as not.
Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by T-R on Thursday January 06, 2011 @04:15PM (#2077213)
I think that's his point.

I feel like the author is so caught up in the view of male sexuality being motivated by a desire to debase women (which would be well supported if we consider the extremes of pornography to be normal), that she fails to make a convincing argument that that underlying desire is in fact the norm.

> While sexual aggression and the desire to debase women may not be what arouse all men, they are certainly an animating force of male sexuality.

I think it's kind of a jump, when looking at how something plays out in the bedroom, to make statements about the motivations (e.g. enforcing male hegemony), particularly when applying it broadly to a large and varying group.

Under her assumption that sexuality isn't egalitarian, and that pornography is an "unvarnished view of male sexuality" in general, she makes some good points, but I think the author fails to substantiate the validity of these assumptions.

As much as the debasement of women in pornography offends me, we need to keep in mind that it's a product, and as such it doesn't necessarily provide deep insight on the consumer or the producer - both of whom are just negotiating to find something that more or less suits their needs at the moment.

Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by sev on Thursday January 06, 2011 @03:58PM (#2077141)
I just don't think that the underlying desire, to make women uncomfortable, is the norm.
Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by philwelch on Thursday January 06, 2011 @05:16PM (#2077519)
It seems more like the author wants to be debased as much as men want to debase her--note how she describes aggressive, debasing, apparently non-committed sex as "the best sex [a woman's] had in her life", and describes her own reaction to that particular encounter as complying "without hesitation".
Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by SapphireSun on Friday January 07, 2011 @01:46AM (#2078846)
I think her compliance is simpler than that. If I believe something for a long time, and finally someone admits it, I cut them some slack, partly because it's funny.
Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by jobrahms on Thursday January 06, 2011 @04:01PM (#2077152)
How can you, or anyone else, profess to know what's normal in bedrooms?
Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by pjscott on Thursday January 06, 2011 @06:45PM (#2077858)
That's actually a really easy question. We look at people's bedroom behavior. There's a whole scientific field on this sort of thing:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexology

Alfred Kinsey, for example, got his fame by scientifically studying what's normal in bedrooms, and publishing this information.

Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by sev on Thursday January 06, 2011 @04:15PM (#2077212)
My point exactly. She does exactly that.
Re:Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women by antidaily on Thursday January 06, 2011 @05:08PM (#2077485)
What she doesn't mention is that the guy was Charlie Sheen.