For me, dealing with codebases generated by the untrained is a daily problem. I do what I can to try and help - I sound like a broken record rattling on about naming variables what they are and whatnot.
You are probably being downvoted because of the second sentence talking bad about self-learned programmers when it's a popular opinion that there are many self-learned programmers.
I personally only downvote when someone is being rude/out of line or says something that is flat-out false, never for opinions. I find HN to be harsh frequently (no specially more so than other inet places but still) and I'm actually a bad day away of taking the route others have taken and just leave.
At least non statisticians are respectful of stats. Doesn't apply to programming.
Most of those I know who have taught themselves code (engineers, physicists, statisticians and mathematicians) in a non-academic environment spurge spaghetti, and I hate them to death.