News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by suprfnk on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:01PM (#20761076)
> Hackable machines are a problem, but they are not the only problem.

They might not be the biggest problem, but they're definitely an _extra_ problem. I don't see what problems they take away, in exchange for bringing this extra problem.

With a paper ballot, I can go to the polling booth, see my vote being counted, and see whether any other funky stuff happens, right there. It's all in the open. This in turn gives you extra trust in the system.

With an electronic system, how do I know what happens behind those layers of abstraction between the user interface and the hardware? How can I in any way verify that my vote has been counted?

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by alistairSH on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:24PM (#20761302)
In VA (or, at least in Fairfax County), we fill in a paper ballot which is scanned by a machine. The vote counting is done by the scanners/electronically, but there is a paper trail for audits. Seems like the best of both worlds (when implemented properly).

Like you, I would have zero faith in an electronic voting booth that simply said "Yup, you pushed a button." I have no idea what actually gets "written to disk".

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by ghaff on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:43PM (#20761572)
Ditto. Fill out a standardized test-like multiple choice form and it gets fed into a reader.
Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by NoodleIncident on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @06:54PM (#20762800)
The reverse also seems fine to me; fill it out in a machine, that shows you the paper ballot it's printing. (Presumably the latter is what gets recounted)
Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by bakuninsbart on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @07:44PM (#20763160)
That is basically useless though. Have it print upfront with a certain amount per district, then hand-fill them out.

There is no difference between making a cross and pushing a button, except that the cross is unique. (There's a case where a guy made a huge anarchy sign on the ballot paper and it was a valid vote because two lines met for a candidate. This is also a thing btw. people should be free to vote as they like. They should be allowed to write in someone else, write "fuck", or draw a huge dick, whatever. Invalid votes are an important part of the electoral process as they signal decidedly uncontent voters.)

I mean especially considering the US, it is beyond ridiculous that this is even a discussion. You guys spend upwards of 2 billion dollars on presidential elections anyway, and then get up in big discussions over a few million dollars on election security.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by 18pfsmt on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @07:55PM (#20763240)
>You guys spend upwards of 2 billion dollars

What is your concern with how our country spends its own money? Where do you live, and let's scrutinize that system like you judge ours?

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by alistairSH on Thursday August 22, 2019 @08:32AM (#20767295)
Whether or not he lives in the US, he is right to express some level of interest in our government (and how it is elected). We're the worlds largest economy (or close to it), the world's largest democracy, and generally what happens here has a massive impact on the rest of the world.

And in this case, he's right. We spend an absurd amount of money on political campaigning, but then get lost in the weeds, and/or hand-wavey, when somebody wants to discuss election security. There are legitimate criticisms of how we process elections.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by 18pfsmt on Thursday August 22, 2019 @06:55PM (#20773120)
Is cable TV programming political campaigning? How about youtube videos funded by the Kochs or Soros?

"Election security," as in mandate, at the federal level, what the states do? Centralizing power (maximizing the possibility of a single point of failures) makes elections more vulnerable. Voting machines are air-gaped. Our elections were influenced by propaganda on social media, just like the Arab Spring.

Evaluating actual 'cause and effect' is helpful when trying to understand situations.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by alistairSH on Friday August 23, 2019 @10:04AM (#20777727)
Is cable TV programming political campaigning? How about youtube videos funded by the Kochs or Soros?

No, that's not campaigning, at least not officially. But, adding those into the mix makes the money spent even more ludicrous.

As for federal mandates, I'm not sure I agree. Right now, states have nearly complete control of the election system, with vastly varying levels of competence. I'm not sure I'd want the federal government mandating which specific machine to use, but I'd love some consistency across states. And also some mandates around vote-by-mail and similar systems.

Air-gapping voting machines only does so much good when nobody outside Diebold knows what the machine does on the inside.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by codedokode on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:43PM (#20761565)
With scanning machines there still is a problem that they can be tampered with and even if you see that the outcome doesn't match exit polls, you don't have any solid proofs to require the manual re-counting of paper ballots.
Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by beat on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:53PM (#20761704)
In most states, if the election is within a certain degree of closeness (like half a percent), it triggers an automatic recount. And that will catch mismatches between the machine counts and the contents of their ballot boxes, unless you also carefully rig the manual recount - at scale.

And altering the count more than a percent or so is a LOT of alteration.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by alistairSH on Thursday August 22, 2019 @08:36AM (#20767330)
Sibling comment is correct - most states will auto-recount within a certain margin. If somebody hacks a difference larger than that, we have a larger problem (ie, not just a machine or two hacked, but the entire system has fallen apart).

And that also brings us back to an earlier comment about driving turnout (or lack thereof) is possibly a larger problem than tampering at the polls. If a party (or somebody acting on behalf of a party) can convince a significant block of voters to stay home, that's more likely to have an impact.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by ascagnel_ on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:15PM (#20761198)
> With a paper ballot, I can go to the polling booth, see my vote being counted, and see whether any other funky stuff happens, right there. It's all in the open. This in turn gives you extra trust in the system.

> With an electronic system, how do I know what happens behind those layers of abstraction between the user interface and the hardware? How can I in any way verify that my vote has been counted?

The best I've seen is a verifiable electronic system with a paper trail. After a voter records their vote electronically, they're shown a "receipt" of their vote to verify it, and the "receipt" is stored securely and anonymously after the user verifies the vote. If the receipt doesn't match their inputs, a red flag can be raised immediately. After the election, the paper records can be used to run a stop-loss audit to verify the electronic vote count. The redundancy has an added benefit -- you're increasing the surface area of the attack itself, and by adding a physical element, you can capture bad actors on camera.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by zanny on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:26PM (#20761336)
> the paper records can be used to run a stop-loss audit to verify the electronic vote count

You can't do this. Probably the most fundamental problem with electronic vote verification is that you cannot give someone physical evidence of how their vote was cast, because it makes voter coercion feasible.

Its why almost all absentee / write in ballots are set up so that if you send multiple ballots only the last one is counted (or an in person vote if you give one). If someone tries to coerce your vote and use the absentee ballot as proof unless they keep you imprisoned until the election is over they can't prove you didn't resubmit / go in person to change your vote.

With receipts for in person ballots the only way to defeat coercion is to make it so you can, at the point of receipt, get issued an intentionally flawed receipt. But if you are verifying votes this way, it would have to be for another legitimate voter voting the exact way your coercer wanted. That sounds like a hugely limiting technical flaw.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by ascagnel_ on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:32PM (#20761423)
> You can't do this. Probably the most fundamental problem with electronic vote verification is that you cannot give someone physical evidence of how their vote was cast, because it makes voter coercion feasible.

There are machines that print paper receipts to voters (presented under glass so voters can verify), and then drop the receipts into a traditional lockable ballot box. The voter cannot access the paper ballot without evidently tampering with the machine; the only issue is that you'd need a way to get poll workers the ballot at issue without identifying the voter.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by brownbat on Thursday August 22, 2019 @12:53AM (#20764746)
> you cannot give someone physical evidence of how their vote was cast, because it makes voter coercion feasible

Some countries try to solve this with an extended voting period and by making votes repudiable / changeable up until the end of the election.

Another solution is generous whistleblower rewards and significant criminal penalties.

There are tools outside the ballot box to prevent crime, and extortion is a crime regardless of whether there's an election going on or not.

(If you bake deniability into your system, you lose the ability to let voters prove to others that their vote was miscounted, so receipts lose a key feature at that point.)

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by wuliwong on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:14PM (#20761191)
>With a paper ballot, I can go to the polling booth, see my vote being counted, and see whether any other funky stuff happens, right there. It's all in the open. This in turn gives you extra trust in the system.

What do you mean you see it counted? I don't think I've ever voted with a paper ballot.

Re:16M Americans will vote on hackable paperless machines by seppin on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:22PM (#20761278)
They are the biggest problem in terms of foreign interference. I don't think a Russian national can hang out in rural Organ and mess with paper ballots without being noticed.