News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by iron0013 on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @11:29AM (#20758142)
Native American anti-pipeline protesters were endlessly demonized and criminalized, violently opposed by both police and privately-funded thugs, yet their concerns were clearly absolutely valid.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ilikehurdles on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @11:39AM (#20758241)
It disgusted me how places like reddit were absolutely, positively swarming with pro-pipeline accounts during that time, defending it as the more cost-effective and environmentally-friendly option.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by criddell on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:33PM (#20758848)
> defending it as the more cost-effective and environmentally-friendly option

Is that not true? What's the best option for transporting oil and gas?

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by jyounker on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:04PM (#20759105)
I think the fundamental issue is that nobody else wanted the pipeline on their land, so it got shoved onto the nominally sovereign Indian tribes where the white man's bullshit always gets pushed. (And I say that as a white man.)
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by amsilprotag on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:32PM (#20759345)
From Robert Caro's The Power Broker:

Robert Moses had shifted the parkway south of Otto Kahn's estate, south of Winthrop's and Mills's estates, south of Stimson's and De Forest's. For men of wealth and influence, he had moved it more than three miles south of its original location. But James Roth possessed neither money nor influence. And for James Roth, Robert Moses would not move the parkway south even one tenth of a mile farther. For James Roth, Robert Moses would not move the parkway one foot.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:36PM (#20758882)
Not transporting it. A better solution can still be a bad solution.

If you absolutely are going to burn it (sigh), burn it on site for electrical generation. Transmission lines don’t leak methane, and HVDC cables can be buried in a similar fashion to a pipeline. Methane extraction aligns well with geographies that have strong renewable growth and need combined cycle gas turbine backing until battery replacement can occur.

Now, if you’re trying to export it and need it in original form, this doesn’t work and you’re going to try to avoid externalities of transport, which is what regulation is for.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ticmasta on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:35PM (#20759386)
Condensate is not typically burned for electrical generation. It's value is as a very low viscosity liquid so it can be blended with heavy oil to make it's transport more efficient. This also necessitates taking it to where the heavier oil is being produced.

It's also typically not composed of methane but propane+, and while there may be a correlation with renewable energy in the same areas, those regions tend to be quite a distance from the ultimate consumers. high capacity electric transportation is not environmentally neutral and underground networks in these areas would be as costly as pipelines, which is why they are almost always above ground.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @04:12PM (#20761180)
These are fair points.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by Aperocky on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:48PM (#20758981)
You can suffer 60% loss on HVDC long range transmission alone, and that's assuming you have the tech for it.

There's a reason why coal is hauled to power station, instead of being burned near mines.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by adrianN on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:53PM (#20759024)
According to the Wikipedia HVDC losses are below 3% per 1000km. To have 60% loss you'd need to transmit the power halfway across the globe.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by Aperocky on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @03:49PM (#20760943)
I stand corrected.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by teh_klev on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:27PM (#20759291)
> There's a reason why coal is hauled to power station, instead of being burned near mines.

Not really.

Power stations need a ready and ample supply of water for power generation and cooling. This is why they can often be a long way from mines and oil/gas fields.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:50PM (#20758998)
Have a citation for those losses? I haven’t seen HVDC lines with losses above single digits.

“HVDC transmission has typically 30-50% less transmission loss than comparable alternating current overhead lines. (For comparison: given 2500 MW transmitted power on 800 km of overhead line, the loss with a conventional 400-kv AC line is 9.4%; with HVDC transmission at 500 kV, it is only 6%, and at 800 kV it is just 2.6%.)” [1]

Also, there are many coal plants sited right at coal mines.

[1] https://www.siemens.com/press/pool/de/events/2012/energy/201...

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by FilterSweep on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:54PM (#20759587)
it’s scary I can no longer tell the difference between paid mercenaries/interns manufacturing consent and reactionaries on reddit
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by calibas on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:01PM (#20758522)
Does anybody know why the story is dropping down so quickly on HN? It's currently 194 points & posted 57 minutes ago, one of the most viral on the front page by far, yet it's gone from #1 to #22 in around 30 minutes.

Edit: Down to #23 since I wrote the comment. It's gotten 200 votes in an hour, should be at least top 5. The #1 and #2 posts have only gotten 49 and 23 votes respectively in the past hour.

Edit 2: Now it's up to #21 & 209 points...

Edit 3: Down to #24 & 228 points...

Edit 4: Up to #20 & 239 points...

Edit 5: Up to #14 & 278 points...

Edit 6: Dropped way down to #40 with 312 points, only 2 hours old...

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by jupiter90000 on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:23PM (#20758761)
I don't know for certain but it seems like ranking is not just by upvotes within a time period, but also what the topic content is, based on how I've seen posts ranked before. Kind of politicized non-tech things don't seem to get priority even if there are lots of upvotes it seems. Just based on my observations, I could be mistaken.

Edit: as others mentioned it could factor in people flagging the post, comment to upvotes ratio, etc

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by root_axis on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:17PM (#20759203)
Politics without a technical tie in?
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by calibas on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @02:19PM (#20759911)
I can understand that, but then why is a post about canine health ranked 10 times higher when it was posted roughly the same time and received 1/3 the votes?

I'm wondering if there's some sort of artificial manipulation going on, as it's a story that's heavily embarrassing to one of the world's most powerful and influential industries.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by root_axis on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @03:16PM (#20760569)
A simpler explanation than artificial manipulation is extreme polarization. This story is a kind of an "egg on the face" moment for one side of the debate, so lots of people have a shared desire for this story to wane without necessarily coordinating to make it disappear.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ijiiijji1 on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:24PM (#20759272)
Bots, shills and morons "steering the sentiment" to confuse, befuddle and seed doubt in people's minds. We have to take decisive action now and be undeterred by BS or games. The billionaires are (indirectly) fking with you to suck more money out of civilization before they isolate themselves in their doom bunkers where they too will eventually die.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ryacko on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:34PM (#20759368)
That seems completely counterintuitive, billionaires already run the world and are directly accountable to impacts to the world economy. I don’t think they are trying to obtain more increments of power or wealth that no one would notice.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by kortilla on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:05PM (#20758573)
But pipelines still are better than trucks. The alternate to the pipeline wasn’t no gas at all.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by metamet on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:35PM (#20758864)
Pipeline is an investment in infrastructure that sets up a sunk cost argument against moving away from oil as a driving source of energy.

"Why would we invest in more clean/green energy sources when we have this brand new pipeline?" It essentially hardens the argument (and subsequent lobbying) for these industries.

I get that it is a huge source of income for folks who travel to and live in these areas. However, it's not a forward looking path--particularly when the environmental impact and costs are so high up front.

In that respect, using trucks--while theoretically having a larger short term impact on emissions--allows for future flexibility and doesn't break into the earth in such a permanent and invasive way.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by pwinnski on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:45PM (#20758958)
"Better" in what sense? A tanker truck that spills its entire load might spill 3,000 gallons or 11,600 gallons[0], a far cry from the 11,000,000 gallons with which this story is concerned.

On that measure, trucks are clearly lower-risk. On other measures, they fare worse. There was also the option of running the pipeline through a different area, but the government claimed that wasn't worth the extra expense, and that there would definitely be no spills like the one there obviously was.

[0] https://www.reference.com/business-finance/many-gallons-tank...

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ticmasta on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:37PM (#20759404)
The alternative to pipelines is not trucks, it's rail, and the impact x frequency of rail-based spills is larger than pipelines.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ilikehurdles on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @06:44PM (#20762730)
No, it isn’t. Pipelines spill far more than rail.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ken on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:00PM (#20759074)
Apart from the words "anti-pipeline", that could describe any of hundreds of events from the past 200 years. Demonizing and persecuting the Sioux, in pursuit of wealth for European settlers, has been going on for as long as the United States have existed.

Even if you know nothing about oil pipelines (and I don't), there's simply no chance this story was going to end with "The First Nations got a raw deal in every interaction with the United States for the past 200 years, but this time it turned out perfectly fine."

The U.S. was a signatory of the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1851. Go check out the area of land which the U.S. agreed to lay no claim to.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ijiiijji1 on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:21PM (#20759242)
The billionaires are killing us and everything, with private security, mercenaries and the police protecting them. We're going to have to fight to overthrow the corporate extinctionists.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by cal5k on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @11:39AM (#20758238)
If it works anything like it does in Canada, the issue is nowhere near as cut and dry as you make it out to be. I'm going to draw comparison to the Canadian situation to illustrate my point.

First, the many native bands in Canada have had a variety of motivations for slowing/blocking the Trans Canada Pipeline project - some have been about environmental protection and preservation of heritage, sure, but a lot of it is political.

Band leaders are, rationally, trying to maximize funds flowing from federal coffers to their bands in the form of grants, subsidies, etc. Some use this funding to help their people, and some don't - it varies widely, just like municipalities do - but holding up infrastructure projects is a tried-and-true method of getting more funding.

While bands are rationally acting in their own self-interest, the government has to strongly consider the interests of the nation, state, region, etc. as a whole.

All of these native concerns, plus the potential environmental impact, have to be weighed against the benefits: fewer petroleum shipments via rail, which is much more dangerous than pipelines, tax revenue, jobs in the oil & gas sector, strategically vital energy security, etc.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ilikehurdles on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @11:43AM (#20758281)
Oil shipments via rail are more dangerous when only measuring deaths caused (such as due to rail accidents). Oil shipped via pipeline is much more likely to spill than rail [1].

Also there's this "pretend that macroeconomics doesn't exist" notion among pro-pipeline hard-liners. By allowing crude oil to be transported in greater quantities without accounting for the permanent environmental costs, we're actively fighting against market forces that make green energy more feasible. If the supply of oil increases, then its prices drop, and the demand for alternatives to fossil fuels lessens.

[1]: Congressional Research Service - https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R43390.pdf

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by cal5k on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:15PM (#20758694)
I completely disagree with that method of promoting renewables, so there's no "we" here. The people who would be most impacted by rising petroleum prices would be those least able to afford it.

America is built on the automobile and most working families can't afford a Tesla at this point - intentionally pushing up oil prices by cutting supply would essentially be a regressive tax.

Tesla is approaching this the right way, however - make electric products that are superior to what's on the market, then aim for economies of scale to dramatically reduce prices and make them affordable. No supply-side manipulation of oil prices necessary, it just takes time.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ilikehurdles on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:26PM (#20758779)
The people most impacted by any price change of any product anywhere are the ones the least able to afford the thing whose price is changing. It’s a cute tautological sound bite that is meaningless without numbers to realize the impact.

There is a real cost to the environment, communities, and people’s health that is completely externalized and unaccounted for by the fossil fuel lobby. It’s a real cost that will eventually be paid by taxes and lives, not a manipulation. Ignoring that cost in the price of oil is the opposite of market-driven.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by cal5k on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:01PM (#20759086)
It's tautological only insofar as you are intentionally ignoring context. If we were talking about the rising price of yachts or some other niche item it would be irrelevant, but almost all working Americans commute.

To address negative externalities there are other proposed solutions - such as a carbon tax - which would not require the intentional scuttling of pipeline projects, although I'm not a huge fan of those either.

My solution would be to walk down the list of emitting sources and tackle each individually. Electricity production is #1, and utility-scale anything is much easier to influence at the policy level. Subsidize the shit out of nuclear and remove the regulatory barriers to getting projects done. Ditto with grid-scale solar and wind.

Transportation is next... get the cost of electric vehicles down by encouraging economies of scale. You can use specific positive incentives here rather than broad-based negative ones.

Anyway, you get the point. Given the complexity of energy policy I find the idea that a soundbite-worthy policy would be the panacea to be laughable. Not building pipelines would just hurt the petroleum industry and have nearly zero measurable impact on carbon emissions.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by jogjayr on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:56PM (#20759041)
> The people who would be most impacted by rising petroleum prices would be those least able to afford it.

The people who will be most impacted by climate change and rising seas will also be those least able to afford it.

You can tax carbon and offset it with a tax credit, so it doesn't hurt poor households as much. British Columbia does it.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by adrianN on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:58PM (#20759054)
The poorest are also least equipped to deal with the consequences of catastrophic global warming.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by cal5k on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:10PM (#20759145)
This we can agree on. You'll note that I never said "global warming isn't real" or that "we should sit on our hands". I criticized this particular policy proposal as being both ineffective and economically punitive.

There are better ways to tackle global warming... I proposed a few ideas above.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ticmasta on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @01:42PM (#20759449)
Even in the wildest dreams of greens we don't displace oil with renewables today. A huge piece of the puzzle is that all the oil delivered to consumers is not equal. Oil produced in Canada, US , Norway, etc is done so under much tighter constraints than the middle east, Africa or parts of S.A., and the beneficiaries match a lot more with the general consensus of "right" than any of these locations.

example: Alberta sits with land-locked oil while eastern Canada imports massive quantities from the middle east because "oil is dirty" when you can see how the sausage is made.

Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by cal5k on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @02:47PM (#20760258)
Exactly. Most policy issues are way more complex than people think, and the proposed solutions way too simplistic to actually work.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by kortilla on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:08PM (#20758607)
Pipeline makes transportation cheaper but doesn’t increase the supply if they were already using trucks. In that case your entire macroeconomics point is wrong unless the pipeline made the difference between profitability and loss.
Re:Whistle-blower reveals N Dakota leak of 11M gallons of ga... by ilikehurdles on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:28PM (#20758800)
It obviously increases the supply in the regions being supplied. Of course I don’t mean that we are creating something out of nothing.