News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IBM Open-Sources Power Chip Instruction Set by gumby on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @06:24AM (#20755970)
Oh I don’t disagree with what you wrote except on one crucial point. Certainly agree that RISC-V is still in its baby shoes.

But IBM’s announcement is simply the ISA itself being open sourced (with some patent IP). Apart from an FPGA soft core there’s no RTL/VHDL. If you want to make silicon you’ll be starting basically from scratch.

Re:IBM Open-Sources Power Chip Instruction Set by tpearson-raptor on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @12:36PM (#20758881)
Sure. While I would also like to see a real hard core or three released, here's my frame challenge:

What if the existing RISC-V and other academic cores are already good enough for a lot of people? The instruction decoder is a relatively small part of the CPU, swap that out and you suddenly get new SoCs that can run the existing POWER software base (that means proven toolchains, vector accelerated applications, etc.). Right now RISC-V doesn't even have vector instructions per se; adding all that support to the entire tooling seems like a lot of effort for not much gain when you can simply implement VSX in the hardware and use the existing tooling for it.

I keep hearing the open RISC-V cores are going to be very fast very soon. If that's true, how would an IBM provided core help versus an instruction decoder swap on one of those and some tuning?