News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by djhworld on Thursday January 06, 2011 @08:34AM (#2075180)
I think the worst culprits are the ones that skim StackOverflow questions and rehash them into their own supposed original "question and answer" site
Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by bartl on Thursday January 06, 2011 @09:13AM (#2075302)
Jeff Atwood discusses this in his most recent Coding Horror blog post (http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2011/01/trouble-in-the-hous...), in which he states that he doesn't really mind people copying StackOverflow questions (and answers), but that he does mind that the copies get a higher Google ranking than the original.
Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by retube on Thursday January 06, 2011 @09:27AM (#2075362)
How does that happen though? efreedom must be doing something special with SEO to get higher than SO given that SO must have huge page rank score.
Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by iuytgyuikoiuy on Thursday January 06, 2011 @09:35AM (#2075396)
Pagerank is based on number/quality of links.

Nobody links to an SO question, except perhaps mentioning it in a blog post. Scrapping sites create lots of links to the question, even if they are low quality ones

Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by retube on Friday January 07, 2011 @05:28AM (#2079179)
Yeah but does anyone link to efreedom question pages? And SO as a whole must have way more inbounds than efreedom, surely?
Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by ergo98 on Thursday January 06, 2011 @09:26AM (#2075355)
What do you think most StackOverflow answers are? It's a karma-paid labor pool where you can post questions and a lot of under-employed people will rush out and do the necessary Google searches, collating and slightly rewriting the results to yield the most votes.

Everyone is ripping off someone's content.

And just to be accurate here, SO content is creative commons (created by the community). Are those just cheap words?

Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by nervechannel on Thursday January 06, 2011 @09:48AM (#2075461)
What do you think most StackOverflow answers are? It's a karma-paid labor pool ... said the comment on Hacker News, earning the poster 3 points so far.
Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by ergo98 on Thursday January 06, 2011 @10:09AM (#2075546)
2 points. I started at one. I desperately hope for more, though, as this is going to give me my big break. I'm trying to earn six more trophies, a ribbon, and link this profile on my resume.
Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by bigfudge on Thursday January 06, 2011 @10:12AM (#2075556)
Except that thare are some genuinely useful compilations on SO which you don't get elsewhere, e.g.: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/72394/what-should-a-devel...

These add significant value to the original content IMO

Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by ergo98 on Thursday January 06, 2011 @10:26AM (#2075602)
Of course there are. It is a community and discussions can be interesting.

However most of the time that I and most people come across SO it's the top search hit for a technical question. The answers are seldom unique, but instead are usually pulled almost word for word from the online manual for the same.

That is overwhelmingly the value of SO -- it benefits by collecting aggregated content from all over the web. It is, hilariously, by design exactly what many in here are complaining about. In that case instead of an automated process it's a mechanical turk.

Hey I don't care because it gets me my answer, but I can see the hilarious paradox in some of the complaints.

I was once searching on a problem -- one that I had faced years earlier but had then forgotten -- and the top link was a SO QA. The answer sounded oddly familiar, when I remembered that it was actually from a blog entry I had posted two years prior.

Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by robryan on Thursday January 06, 2011 @11:25AM (#2075887)
stackoverflow consistently provides high quality answers though. If someone was to come along, take the creative commons material and present it in a way that actually improved my experience of finding the answer I was after I'd be all for it.

In my experience though the sites that are taking the content are ad ridden messes which remove value rather than add anything.

Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by ergo98 on Thursday January 06, 2011 @11:59AM (#2076091)
Totally agree with that. There is an opportunity for someone to take the content and actually improve on it somehow (e.g. an expert engine or something, or better machine driven ontological navigation, etc), however it thus far its just been improving the SEO of it.
Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by jonhendry on Thursday January 06, 2011 @03:42PM (#2077064)
" It's a karma-paid labor pool where you can post questions and a lot of under-employed people will rush out and do the necessary Google searches"

Maybe it's like that in your field, but in Mac dev questions you're fairly likely to get answers from established OS X developers, and even Apple employees.

Re:Dear Google: please let me ban sites from results by djhworld on Thursday January 06, 2011 @12:04PM (#2076107)
It's not the answers I'm bothered about, it's just how they spam my search feed. I whack in some queries to google and the first 10 results will just be the same SO question but spread over multiple different sites.