Re:Judge claims mobile phone is not a computer
by dagw on Monday August 19, 2019 @11:00AM
(#20738330)
It's an interesting philosophical question if nothing else. If a law is unclear, to what extent should a judge be deciding what the law “should" say vs. going with what's on the page and telling the lawmakers that they need to clarify their intentions.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Judge claims mobile phone is not a computer
by cr0sh on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:37PM
(#20740446)
I guess it's ultimately what - if anything - the law in question (or whatever it may reference) defines a "computer" as (legally).
Maybe the definition on the books says a computer is a device with a screen and a keyboard, and maybe other input/output devices like a printer or a mouse. Maybe it says something about typing on a computer, or sitting down at a computer, or such? It probably doesn't do anything like reference what the technical definition of a computer is (and funnily enough, if it did - even that would likely be wrong, and exclude things like analog computers, relay machines, mechanical differential analyzers, and a whole host of other things which historically and otherwise are "computers").